A Preconditioned Multiple Shooting Shadowing Algorithm for the Sensitivity Analysis of Chaotic Systems

TL;DR

This paper introduces a preconditioned MSS algorithm with a block diagonal preconditioner for efficient sensitivity analysis in chaotic systems, demonstrating significant convergence improvements and applicability to large-scale problems.

Contribution

It develops a matrix-free, parallelizable preconditioner for MSS, enhancing convergence and enabling sensitivity analysis of large chaotic systems like turbulence.

Findings

Preconditioner accelerates MSS convergence.

Eigenvalue bracketing improves stability and speed.

Method closely matches finite difference sensitivities.

Abstract

We propose a preconditioner that can accelerate the rate of convergence of the Multiple Shooting Shadowing (MSS) method. This recently proposed method can be used to compute derivatives of time-averaged objectives (also known as sensitivities) to system parameter(s) for chaotic systems. We propose a block diagonal preconditioner, which is based on a partial singular value decomposition of the MSS constraint matrix. The preconditioner can be computed using matrix-vector products only (i.e. it is matrix-free) and is fully parallelised in the time domain. Two chaotic systems are considered, the Lorenz system and the 1D Kuramoto Sivashinsky equation. Combination of the preconditioner with a regularisation method leads to tight bracketing of the eigenvalues to a narrow range. This combination results in a significant reduction in the number of iterations, and renders the convergence rate almost independent of the number of degrees of freedom of the system, and the length of the trajectory that is used to compute the time-averaged objective. This can potentially allow the method to be used for large chaotic systems (such as turbulent flows) and optimal control applications. The singular value decomposition of the constraint matrix can also be used to quantify the effect of the system condition on the accuracy of the sensitivities. In fact, neglecting the singular modes affected by noise, we recover the correct values of sensitivity that match closely with those obtained with finite differences for the Kuramoto Sivashinsky equation in the light turbulent regime.