A comparison between RAVE DR5 and Gaia DR2 Radial Velocities

TL;DR

This paper compares radial velocities from RAVE DR5 and Gaia DR2, confirming overall agreement, identifying systematic offsets, and pinpointing specific stars with large velocity discrepancies due to pipeline issues.

Contribution

It provides a detailed comparison between RAVE DR5 and Gaia DR2 radial velocities, highlighting systematic offsets and identifying a subset of stars affected by pipeline calibration problems.

Findings

Overall excellent agreement between RAVE DR5 and Gaia DR2 velocities.

Systematic offset of about -0.32 km/s consistent with Gaia DR2 findings.

Identification of 707 stars with large velocity offsets due to pipeline calibration issues.

Abstract

This research note presents a comparison of radial velocities between the RAVE DR5 data release with Gaia DR2. RAVE DR5 and Gaia DR2 have 450587 stars in common. In particular we would like to shed light on a small subset of joint targets (707 stars) that exhibit a constant velocity offset of +105 km/s or -76 km/s, respectively. Overall this comparison confirms the excellent agreement between those two data sets. The velocity differences can well be matched with two Gaussians with FWHM of 1.2 km/s and 3.6 km/s, respectively. There is a systematic offset of about -0.32 km/s, consistent with the findings in Gaia DR2, who find an offset of -0.29 km/s. The offset is also comparable to the offset found between Gaia DR2 and other ground-based spectroscopic surveys in a similar magnitude range, indicative that the source for this offset may at least partially be related to the radial velocity zeropoint of Gaia DR2. We identified 707 stars that exhibit large constant velocity offsets. These cases can be traced to a problem of the reduction pipeline in propagating the wavelength calibration between neighboring fibres near the edges of the field plate, in particular for observations done just before fibre repairs, i.e. when live fibres were separated by large gaps of broken ones. In 82\%\ of these cases the offset between RAVE DR5 and Gaia DR2 radial velocity is in the $+105 \pm 15$~\kms range. These spectra belong to the first 10 fibres of the field plate. Another 3\%\ of the spectra have velocity offset in the $-76 \pm 4$~\kms range and were observed with the fibres 148-150. Even though the majority of these 707 stars do not exhibit any particularity in the radial velocity, we recommend excluding them from future studies.