No Evidence for Millimeter Continuum Source Overdensities in the Environments of $z\gtrsim6$ Quasars

TL;DR

This study used ALMA 1.2mm dust continuum maps of 35 high-redshift quasars to search for galaxy overdensities, finding no significant excess of dusty galaxies near the quasars, suggesting the need for larger or different scale surveys.

Contribution

The paper provides the first systematic millimeter continuum survey around $z>6$ quasars, highlighting limitations and considerations for detecting early galaxy overdensities.

Findings

No significant overdensity of dusty galaxies detected near quasars.

ALMA's small field of view may miss larger-scale overdensities.

Continuum surveys might underestimate true galaxy overdensities due to line-of-sight effects.

Abstract

Bright high-redshift quasars ($z>6$), hosting supermassive black holes ($\rm M_{BH} > 10^8 M_{\odot}$), are expected to reside in massive host galaxies embedded within some of the earliest and most massive galaxy overdensities. We analyze 1.2\,mm ALMA dust continuum maps of 35 bright quasars at $6<z<7$ and search the primary beam for excess dust continuum emission from sources with L$_{\rm IR} \gtrsim{ 10^{12}}$\,L$_{\odot}$ as evidence for early protoclusters. We compare the detection rates of continuum sources at $\geq5\sigma$ significance in the fields surrounding the quasars (A$_{\rm eff}$ = 4.3\,arcmin$^2$) with millimeter number counts in blank field surveys. We discover 15 millimeter sources in the fields excluding the quasars themselves, corresponding to an overdensity $\delta_{\rm gal} \equiv (N_{\rm gal} - N_{\rm exp})/N_{\rm exp} = -0.07\pm0.56$, consistent with no detected overdensity of dusty galaxies within 140 physical kpc of the quasars. However, the apparent lack of continuum overdensity does not negate the hypothesis that quasars live in overdense environments, as evidenced by strong [CII] overdensities found on the same scales to similarly-selected quasars. The small field of view of ALMA could miss a true overdensity if it exists on scales larger than 1\,cMpc, if the quasar is not centered in the overdensity, or if quasar feedback plays a role close to the quasar, but it is most likely that the large line of sight volume probed by a continuum survey will wash out a true overdensity signal. We discuss the necessary factors in determining the bias with which dusty star-forming galaxies trace true dark matter overdensities in order to improve upon overdensity searches in dust continuum.