Disparity among low first ionization potential elements

TL;DR

This study examines the variability of the FIP effect among low FIP elements in the solar wind, revealing that Fe behaves differently from Mg and Si, indicating that fractionation is influenced by factors beyond FIP alone.

Contribution

It provides a detailed analysis of the FIP effect's dependence on charge state ratios, highlighting differences among low FIP elements and challenging existing fractionation models.

Findings

Fe shows different FIP behavior compared to Mg and Si during solar maximum.

FIP effect for Mg and Si increases with O7+/O6+ ratio, unlike Fe.

Fe's FIP distribution is broader and exhibits a peak, indicating complex fractionation processes.

Abstract

The elemental composition of the solar wind differs from the solar photospheric composition. Elements with low first ionization potential (FIP) appear enhanced compared to O in the solar wind relative to the respective photospheric abundances. This so-called FIP effect is different in the slow solar wind and the coronal hole wind. However, under the same plasma conditions, for elements with similar FIPs such as Mg, Si, and Fe, comparable enhancements are expected. We scrutinize the assumption that the FIP effect is always similar for different low FIP elements, namely Mg, Si, and Fe. We investigate the dependency of the FIP effect of low FIP elements on the O7+/O6+ charge state ratio depending on time and solar wind type. We order the observed FIP ratios with respect to the O7+/O6+ charge state ratio into bins and analyze separately the respective distributions of the FIP ratio of Mg, Si, and Fe for each O7+/O6+ charge state ratio bin. We observe that the FIP effect shows the same qualitative yearly behavior for Mg and Si, while Fe shows significant differences during the solar activity maximum and its declining phase. In each year, the FIP effect for Mg and Si always increases with increasing O7+/O6+ charge state ratio, but for high O7+/O6+ charge state ratios the FIP effect for Fe shows a qualitatively different behavior. During the years 2001-2006, instead of increasing with the O7+/O6+ charge state ratio, the Fe FIP ratio exhibits a broad peak. Also, the FIP distribution per O7+/O6+ charge state bin is significantly broader for Fe than for Mg and Si. These observations support the conclusion that the elemental fractionation is only partly determined by FIP. In particular, the qualitative difference behavior with increasing O7+/O6+ charge state ratio between Fe on the one hand and Mg and Si on the other hand is not yet well explained by models of fractionation.