5G Massive MIMO Architectures: Self-Backhauled Small Cells versus Direct Access

TL;DR

This paper compares 5G massive MIMO architectures, specifically self-backhauled small cells and direct access, analyzing their performance through simulations and proposing deployment strategies to enhance user rates.

Contribution

It introduces a comprehensive comparison of self-backhauled small cells and direct access architectures, including new deployment strategies and resource partitioning analysis.

Findings

Ad-hoc deployment with directive antennas improves cell-edge rates by up to 30%.

Optimal resource partitioning enhances performance of self-backhauled small cells.

Direct access architecture outperforms self-backhauling when pilot contamination is low.

Abstract

In this paper, we focus on one of the key technologies for the fifth-generation wireless communication networks, massive multiple-input-multiple-output (mMIMO), by investigating two of its most relevant architectures: 1) to provide in-band backhaul for the ultra-dense network (UDN) of self-backhauled small cells (SCs), and 2) to provide direct access (DA) to user equipments (UEs). Through comprehensive 3GPP-based system-level simulations and analytical formulations, we show the end-to-end UE rates achievable with these two architectures. Differently from the existing works, we provide results for two strategies of self-backhauled SC deployments, namely random and ad-hoc, where in the latter SCs are purposely positioned close to UEs to achieve line-of-sight (LoS) access links. We also evaluate the optimal backhaul and access time resource partition due to the in-band self-backhauling (s-BH) operations. Our results show that the ad-hoc deployment of self-backhauled SCs closer to the UEs with optimal resource partition and with directive antenna patterns, provides rate improvements for cell-edge UEs that amount to 30% and tenfold gain, as compared to mMIMO DA architecture with pilot reuse 3 and reuse 1, respectively. On the other hand, mMIMO s-BH underperforms mMIMO DA above the median value of the UE rates when the effect of pilot contamination is less severe, and the LoS probability of the DA links improves.