Affine Geometry, Visual Sensation, and Preference for Symmetry of Things in a Thing

TL;DR

This paper explores how geometric symmetry, especially fractal symmetry, influences visual perception and aesthetic preference, highlighting the importance of symmetry in natural forms and its perceptual effects.

Contribution

It introduces experimental evidence on how fractal symmetry affects aesthetic judgments and preference, linking geometry with visual sensation and decision-making.

Findings

Reduced perceived attractiveness with increased fractal deviation from symmetry

Symmetry significantly influences aesthetic preference and visual perception

Potential for future research on complexity and symmetry in visual aesthetics

Abstract

Evolution and geometry generate complexity in similar ways. Evolution drives natural selection while geometry may capture the logic of this selection and express it visually, in terms of specific generic properties representing some kind of advantage. Geometry is ideally suited for expressing the logic of evolutionary selection for symmetry, which is found in the shape curves of vein systems and other natural objects such as leaves, cell membranes, or tunnel systems built by ants. The topology and geometry of symmetry is controlled by numerical parameters, which act in analogy with a biological organism's DNA. The introductory part of this paper reviews findings from experiments illustrating the critical role of two-dimensional design parameters and shape symmetry for visual or tactile shape sensation, and for perception-based decision making in populations of experts and non-experts. Thereafter, results from a pilot study on the effects of fractal symmetry, referred to herein as the symmetry of things in a thing, on aesthetic judgments and visual preference are presented. In a first experiment (psychophysical scaling procedure), non-expert observers had to rate (scale from 0 to 10) the perceived attractiveness of a random series of 2D fractal trees with varying degrees of fractal symmetry. In a second experiment (two-alternative forced choice procedure), they had to express their preference for one of two shapes from the series. The shape pairs were presented successively in random order. Results show that the smallest possible fractal deviation from "symmetry of things in a thing" significantly reduces the perceived attractiveness of such shapes. The potential of future studies where different levels of complexity of fractal patterns are weighed against different degrees of symmetry is pointed out in the conclusion.