Response to "Reply to comment on 'Divergent and Ultrahigh Thermal Conductivity in Millimeter-Long Nanotubes'"

TL;DR

This paper provides a detailed response to Prof. Chang et al.'s reply concerning their claims of divergent and ultrahigh thermal conductivity in millimeter-long nanotubes, clarifying the scientific debate.

Contribution

The paper offers a comprehensive rebuttal to previous claims, clarifying the scientific discussion on thermal conductivity in nanotubes.

Findings

Clarifies the scientific debate on nanotube thermal conductivity

Responds to specific points raised in the reply

Provides detailed counterarguments to previous claims

Abstract

More than one year ago, Prof. Chih-Wei Chang and the co-authors published "Divergent and Ultrahigh Thermal Conductivity in Millimeter-Long Nanotubes" in PRL and we submitted a comment. After some while we received Prof. Chang et al.'s reply, which is almost the same as their arXiv preprint, and responded to the reply promptly. On the request of some readers, I personally post here the detailed response to "Reply to comment on 'Divergent and Ultrahigh Thermal Conductivity in Millimeter-Long Nanotubes'".