On the low magnetic field effect in radical pair reactions

TL;DR

This paper provides a detailed analysis of the low magnetic field effect in radical pair reactions, clarifying the nature of transitions involved and explaining experimental observations with theoretical and simulation approaches.

Contribution

It offers a comprehensive explanation of the low field effect, identifying S to T0 transitions as key, and applies this understanding to interpret experimental biphasic and triphasic magnetic field effects.

Findings

Low field effect involves S to T0 transitions, not S to T± as previously thought.

The analysis applies to radical pairs with single proton or many hyperfine-coupled spins.

Simulation results match observed biphasic-triphasic transitions in radical pair survival probabilities.

Abstract

Radical pair recombination reactions are known to be sensitive to the application of both low and high magnetic fields. The application of a weak magnetic field reduces the singlet yield of a singlet-born radical pair, whereas the application of a strong magnetic field increases the singlet yield. The high field effect arises from energy conservation: when the magnetic field is stronger than the sum of the hyperfine fields in the two radicals, ${\rm S}\to {\rm T}_{\pm}$ transitions become energetically forbidden, thereby reducing the number of pathways for singlet to triplet interconversion. The low field effect arises from symmetry breaking: the application of a weak magnetic field lifts degeneracies among the zero field eigenstates and increases the number of pathways for singlet to triplet interconversion. However, the details of this effect are more subtle, and have not previously been properly explained. Here we present a complete analysis of the low field effect in a radical pair containing a single proton, and in a radical pair in which one of the radicals contains a large number of hyperfine-coupled nuclear spins. We find that the new transitions that occur when the field is switched on are between ${\rm S}$ and ${\rm T}_0$ in both cases, and not between ${\rm S}$ and ${\rm T}_{\pm}$ as has previously been claimed. We then illustrate this result by using it in conjunction with semiclassical spin dynamics simulations to account for the observation of a biphasic--triphasic--biphasic transition with increasing magnetic field strength in the magnetic field effect on the time-dependent survival probability of a photoexcited carotenoid-porphyrin-fullerene radical pair.