Better insight into the Strutinsky method (published version)

TL;DR

This paper offers a new, clearer understanding of Strutinsky's method, highlighting its dependence on two parameters and proposing an improved criterion for parameter selection, thus clarifying its relationship with semi-classical approaches.

Contribution

It introduces a new criterion for selecting the smoothing parameter in Strutinsky's method, replacing the traditional plateau condition, and clarifies the role of the curvature correction order.

Findings

Proposes a new criterion for the smoothing parameter.

Shows the curvature correction order has an accessory role.

Provides a definitive insight into the method's relationship with semi-classical approaches.

Abstract

Strutinsky's method is reviewed through a new understanding. This method depends on two free parameters: The smoothing parameter and the order of the curvature correction. It turns out that this method is nothing but a compromise between two fundamental conditions which are the so-called asymptotic limit which comes from the so-called remainder which imposes a small as possible smoothing parameter and the smoothing condition which forces that parameter to be, at least, slightly larger than the inter shell spacing. In this paper, to find the best value of the smoothing parameter, a new criterion is proposed instead of the plateau condition . This new criterion is much more clear and free from ambiguities of the usual plateau condition. It is also found, that the second free parameter, i.e., the order of the curvature correction, plays an accessory role since, it is connected intimately to the smoothing parameter, when the smoothing is realized. This paper provides a new and definitive insight into Strutinsky's method and its relationship with semi-classical methods.