On the Origin of the Early Solar System Radioactivities. Problems with the AGB and Massive Star Scenarios

TL;DR

This paper critically examines the origins of extinct radioactivities in the early solar system, highlighting difficulties in explaining certain isotopes through AGB and massive star scenarios, and suggesting the need for alternative explanations.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive re-evaluation of stellar nucleosynthesis models, identifying specific challenges in accounting for observed radioisotope ratios in the solar nebula.

Findings

Galactic inheritance explains most radioactivities.

AGB and massive star models struggle to reproduce certain isotope ratios.

Inhomogeneous supernova contamination introduces additional problems.

Abstract

Recent improvements in stellar models for intermediate-mass and massive stars are recalled, together with their expectations for the synthesis of radioactive nuclei of lifetime $\tau \lesssim 25$ Myr, in order to re-examine the origins of now extinct radioactivities, which were alive in the solar nebula. The Galactic inheritance broadly explains most of them, especially if $r$-process nuclei are produced by neutron star merging according to recent models. Instead, $^{26}$Al, $^{41}$Ca, $^{135}$Cs and possibly $^{60}$Fe require nucleosynthesis events close to the solar formation. We outline the persisting difficulties to account for these nuclei by Intermediate Mass Stars (2 $\lesssim $ M/M$_\odot \lesssim 7 - 8$). Models of their final stages now predict the ubiquitous formation of a $^{13}$C reservoir as a neutron capture source; hence, even in presence of $^{26}$Al production from Deep Mixing or Hot Bottom Burning, the ratio $^{26}$Al/$^{107}$Pd remains incompatible with measured data, with a large excess in $^{107}$Pd. This is shown for two recent approaches to Deep Mixing. Even a late contamination by a Massive Star meets problems. In fact, inhomogeneous addition of Supernova debris predicts non-measured excesses on stable isotopes. Revisions invoking specific low-mass supernovae and/or the sequential contamination of the pre-solar molecular cloud might be affected by similar problems, although our conclusions here are weakened by our schematic approach to the addition of SN ejecta. The limited parameter space remaining to be explored for solving this puzzle is discussed.