Bottom-up versus top-down control and the transfer of information in complex model ecosystems

TL;DR

This paper introduces an information-theoretic framework to quantify the balance of bottom-up and top-down control in ecological systems, demonstrating how community control shifts during succession.

Contribution

It provides a novel mathematical approach to measure the influence of natural selection and coadaptation in ecosystem evolution using the Tangled Nature Model.

Findings

Ecological communities shift from bottom-up to top-down control during succession.

Species with higher influence on selection tend to be more abundant.

Systemic control becomes more prominent as ecosystems develop.

Abstract

Ecological systems are emergent features of ecological and adaptive dynamics of a community of interacting species. By natural selection through the abiotic environment and by co-adaptation within the community, species evolve, thereby giving rise to the ecological networks we regard as ecosystems. This reductionist perspective can be contrasted with the view that as species have to fit in the surrounding system, the system itself exerts selection pressure on the evolutionary pathways of the species. This interplay of bottom-up and top-down control in the development and growth of ecological systems has long been discussed, however empirical ecosystem data is scarce and a comprehensive mathematical framework is lacking. We present a way of quantifying the relative weight of natural selection and coadaptation grounded in information theory, to assess the relative role of bottom-up and top-down control in the evolution of ecological systems, and analyse the information transfer in an individual based stochastic complex systems model, the Tangled Nature Model of evolutionary ecology. We show that ecological communities evolve from mainly bottom-up controlled early-successional systems to more strongly top-down controlled late-successional systems, as coadaptation progresses. Species which have a high influence on selection are also generally more abundant. Hence our findings imply that ecological communities are shaped by a dialogue of bottom-up and top-down control, where the role of the systemic selection and integrity becomes more pronounced the further the ecosystem is developed.