Limitations of Pseudo-Newtonian approach in studying the accretion flow around Kerr black hole

TL;DR

This study compares relativistic, semi-relativistic, and non-relativistic accretion flows around Kerr black holes, showing semi-relativistic models with an effective potential closely mimic relativistic flows, unlike non-relativistic ones.

Contribution

It demonstrates that semi-relativistic accretion models with an effective potential effectively replicate relativistic flow properties around Kerr black holes, unlike non-relativistic models.

Findings

Relativistic and semi-relativistic flows show good agreement in transonic properties.

Shock properties are consistent between relativistic and semi-relativistic flows.

Non-relativistic flows significantly deviate in shock position and parameter space.

Abstract

We study the relativistic accretion flow around a generic stationary axisymmetric space-time and obtain an effective potential ($\Phi^{\rm eff}$) that accurately mimics the general relativistic features of Kerr black hole having spin $0\le a_k <1$. Considering the accretion disc confined around the equatorial plane of a rotating black hole and using the relativistic equation of state, we examine the properties of the relativistic accretion flow and compare it with the same obtained form semi-relativistic as well as non-relativistic accretion flows. Towards this, we first investigate the transonic properties of the accretion flow around the rotating black hole where good agreement is observed for relativistic and semi-relativistic flows. Further, we study the non-linearities such as shock waves in accretion flow. Here also we find that the shock properties are in agreement for both relativistic and semi-relativistic flows irrespective of the black hole spin ($a_k$), although it deviates significantly for non-relativistic flow. In fact, when the particular shocked solutions are compared for flows with identical outer boundary conditions, the positions of shock transition in relativistic and semi-relativistic flows agree well with deviation of $6-12\%$ for $0 \le a_k \le 0.99$, but vast disagreement is observed for non-relativistic flow. In addition, we compare the parameter space for shock to establish the fact that relativistic as well as semi-relativistic accretion flow dynamics do show close agreement irrespective of $a_k$ values, whereas non-relativistic flow fails to do so. With these findings, we point out that semi-relativistic flow including $\Phi^{\rm eff}$ satisfactorily mimics the relativistic accretion flows around Kerr black hole. Finally, we discuss the possible implications of this work in the context of dissipative advective accretion flow around Kerr black holes.