Bulk scaling in wall-bounded and homogeneous vertical natural convection

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that bulk-dominated vertical natural convection exhibits a 1/2 power-law scaling of Nusselt and Reynolds numbers with Rayleigh number, similar to homogeneous RBC, indicating a universal bulk behavior.

Contribution

It extends the understanding of scaling laws to vertical natural convection without walls, showing bulk behavior aligns with homogeneous RBC predictions.

Findings

Bulk Nusselt and Reynolds numbers follow a 1/2 power-law scaling with Rayleigh number.

Homogeneous vertical natural convection exhibits unsteady dynamics at low to moderate Rayleigh numbers.

The 1/2 scaling law may be observable at lower Rayleigh numbers when using bulk flow quantities.

Abstract

Previous numerical studies on homogeneous Rayleigh-B\'enard convection, which is Rayleigh-B\'enard convection (RBC) without walls, and therefore without boundary layers, have revealed a scaling regime that is consistent with theoretical predictions of bulk-dominated thermal convection. In this so-called asymptotic regime, previous studies have predicted that the Nusselt number ($Nu$) and the Reynolds number ($Re$) vary with the Rayleigh number ($Ra$) according to $Nu\sim Ra^{1/2}$ and $Re\sim Ra^{1/2}$ at small Prandtl number ($Pr$). In this study, we consider a flow that is similar to RBC but with the direction of temperature gradient perpendicular to gravity instead of parallel; we refer to this configuration as vertical natural convection (VC). Since the direction of the temperature gradient is different in VC, there is no exact relation for the average kinetic dissipation rate, which makes it necessary to explore alternative definitions for $Nu$, $Re$ and $Ra$ and to find physical arguments for closure, rather than making use of the exact relation between $Nu$ and the dissipation rates as in RBC. Once we remove the walls from VC to obtain the homogeneous setup, we find that the aforementioned $1/2$-power-law scaling is present, similar to the case of homogeneous RBC. When focussing on the bulk, we find that the Nusselt and Reynolds numbers in the bulk of VC too exhibit the $1/2$-power-law scaling. These results suggest that the $1/2$-power-law scaling may even be found at lower Rayleigh numbers if the appropriate quantities in the turbulent bulk flow are employed for the definitions of $Ra$, $Re$ and $Nu$. From a stability perspective, at low- to moderate-$Ra$, we find that the time-evolution of the Nusselt number for homogenous vertical natural convection is unsteady, which is consistent with the nature of the elevator modes reported in previous studies on homogeneous RBC.