The Many Shapes of Archive-It

TL;DR

This paper explores structural metadata in Archive-It web collections to understand their curation and crawling behaviors, enabling automatic semantic categorization with high accuracy, thus saving time and resources.

Contribution

It introduces structural features and a classification method to categorize Archive-It collections, bridging structural data with semantic understanding.

Findings

Random Forest classifier achieved 0.720 F1 score in predicting collection categories.

Structural features effectively reveal curation and crawling behaviors.

Method reduces time and bandwidth needed for collection analysis.

Abstract

Web archives, a key area of digital preservation, meet the needs of journalists, social scientists, historians, and government organizations. The use cases for these groups often require that they guide the archiving process themselves, selecting their own original resources, or seeds, and creating their own web archive collections. We focus on the collections within Archive-It, a subscription service started by the Internet Archive in 2005 for the purpose of allowing organizations to create their own collections of archived web pages, or mementos. Understanding these collections could be done via their user-supplied metadata or via text analysis, but the metadata is applied inconsistently between collections and some Archive-It collections consist of hundreds of thousands of seeds, making it costly in terms of time to download each memento. Our work proposes using structural metadata as an additional way to understand these collections. We explore structural features currently existing in these collections that can unveil curation and crawling behaviors. We adapt the concept of the collection growth curve for understanding Archive-It collection curation and crawling behavior. We also introduce several seed features and come to an understanding of the diversity of resources that make up a collection. Finally, we use the descriptions of each collection to identify four semantic categories of Archive-It collections. Using the identified structural features, we reviewed the results of runs with 20 classifiers and are able to predict the semantic category of a collection using a Random Forest classifier with a weighted average F1 score of 0.720, thus bridging the structural to the descriptive. Our method is useful because it saves the researcher time and bandwidth. Identifying collections by their semantic category allows further downstream processing to be tailored to these categories.