Capillary Forces on a Small Particle at a Liquid-Vapor Interface: Theory and Simulation

TL;DR

This paper combines theory and simulation to analyze the capillary forces on small particles at liquid-vapor interfaces, revealing scale-dependent behaviors and the importance of interface span in experimental interpretation.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive study of meniscus behavior and capillary forces across nanometer to macroscopic scales, integrating macroscopic theory, molecular dynamics simulations, and experimental comparisons.

Findings

Meniscus height grows as ln(2L/R) for R << L << capillary length.

Capillary force is linearly proportional to particle displacement with a scale-dependent spring constant.

Finite interface span significantly affects force measurements at scales near the capillary length.

Abstract

We study the meniscus on the outside of a small spherical particle with radius $R$ at a liquid-vapor interface. The liquid is confined in a cylindrical container with a finite radius $L$ and has a contact angle $\pi/2$ at the container surface. The center of the particle is placed at various heights along the central axis of the container. By varying $L$, we are able to systematically study the crossover of the meniscus from nanometer to macroscopic scales. The meniscus rise or depression on the particle is found to grow as $\ln (2L/R)$ when $R\ll L\ll \kappa^{-1}$ with $\kappa^{-1}$ being the capillary length and saturate to a value predicted by the Derjaguin-James formula when $R \ll \kappa^{-1} \ll L$. The capillary force on the particle exhibits a linear dependence on the particle's displacement from its equilibrium position at the interface when the displacement is small. The associated spring constant is found to be $2\pi\gamma\ln^{-1} (2L/R)$ for $L\ll \kappa^{-1}$ and saturates to $2\pi\gamma\ln^{-1} (3.7\kappa^{-1}/R)$ for $L\gg \kappa^{-1}$. At nanometer scales, we perform molecular dynamics simulations of the described geometry and the results agree well with the predictions of the macroscopic theory of capillarity. At micrometer to macroscopic scales, comparison to experiments by Anachkov \textit{et al.} [Soft Matter {\bf 12}, 7632 (2016)] shows that the finite span of a liquid-vapor or liquid-liquid interface needs to be considered to interpret experimental data collected with $L \sim \kappa^{-1}$.