3D instabilities and negative eddy viscosity in thin-layer flows

TL;DR

This paper investigates the stability of thin-layer flows against 3D and 2D perturbations, revealing conditions for instabilities and inverse cascade phenomena, with implications for turbulent flow behavior as layer thickness varies.

Contribution

It introduces a stability analysis framework for thin-layer flows using Floquet-Bloch methods, identifying thresholds for 3D and 2D instabilities and their coexistence.

Findings

3D instabilities occur when layer thickness exceeds a critical value related to Reynolds number.

Large-scale 2D perturbations become unstable via eddy viscosity mechanisms at high Reynolds numbers.

The study constructs a stability diagram outlining regions of 2D and 3D instability coexistence.

Abstract

The stability of flows in layers of finite thickness $H$ is examined against small scale three dimensional (3D) perturbations and large scale two-dimensional (2D) perturbations. The former provide an indication of a forward transfer of energy while the later indicate an inverse transfer and the possibility of an inverse cascade. The analysis is performed using a Floquet-Bloch code that allows to examine the stability of modes with arbitrary large scale separation. For thin layers the 3D perturbations become unstable when the layer thickness $H$ becomes larger than $H > c_1 (\nu \ell_{_U}/U)^{1/2}= c_1 \ell_{_U} Re^{-1/2}$, where $U$ is the rms velocity of the flown, $\ell_{_U}$ is the correlation length scale of the flow, $\nu$ the viscosity and $Re=\ell_{_U} U/\nu$ is the Reynolds number. At the same time large scale 2D perturbations also become unstable by an eddy viscosity mechanism when $Re>c_2$, where $c_1,c_2$ are order one non-dimensional numbers. These relations define different regions in parameter space where 2D and 3D instabilities can (co-)exist and this allows to construct a stability diagram. Implications of these results for fully turbulent flows that display a change of direction of cascade as $H$ is varied are discussed.