Deep secrets of intermediate-mass giants and supergiants: Models with rotation seem to overestimate mixing effects on the surface abundances of C, N, and Na

TL;DR

This study investigates surface abundances of C, N, O, Na, and Al in intermediate-mass giants and Cepheids, revealing that models with rotation overestimate mixing effects, and Na abundance plateaus around 2.5 Msun.

Contribution

It extends the analysis of surface abundances to stars more massive than 3 Msun and compares observations with models, highlighting issues with rotation-induced mixing predictions.

Findings

Na abundance reaches a plateau at about 2.5 Msun.

Models with rotation overestimate mixing effects.

Most observed abundances align with non-rotating models.

Abstract

Recent observational results have demonstrated an increase in the surface Na abundance that correlates with stellar mass for red giants between 2 and 3 Msun. This trend supports evolutionary mixing processes as the explanation for Na overabundances seen in some red giants. In this same mass range, the surface Al abundance was shown to be constant. Our main aim was to extend the investigation of the Na and Al surface abundances to giants more massive than 3 Msun. We sought to establish accurately whether the Na abundances keep increasing with stellar mass or a plateau is reached. In addition, we investigated whether mixing can affect the surface abundance of Al in giants more massive than 3 Msun. We obtained new high-resolution spectra of 20 giants in the field of 10 open clusters; 17 of these stars were found to be members of 9 clusters. The giants have masses between 2.5 Msun and 5.6 Msun. Abundances of C, N, and O were determined using spectrum synthesis. The abundances of Na and Al were corrected for non-local thermodynamic equilibrium effects (non-LTE). Moreover, to extend the mass range of our sample, we collected from the literature high-quality C, N, O, and Na abundances of 32 Galactic Cepheids with accurate masses in the range between 3 Msun and 14 Msun. The surface abundances of C, N, O, Na, and Al were compared to predictions of stellar evolution models with and without the inclusion of rotation-induced mixing. The surface abundances of most giants and Cepheids of the sample can be explained by models without rotation. For giants above ~ 2.5 Msun, the Na abundances reach a plateau level of about [Na/Fe] ~ 0.20-0.25 dex (in non-LTE). Our results support previous works that found models with rotation to overestimate the mixing effects in intermediate-mass stars. [abridged]