The Equivalence Principle at Work in Radiation from Unaccelerated Atoms and Mirrors

TL;DR

This paper explores how the equivalence principle manifests in radiation phenomena involving atoms, mirrors, and detectors in accelerated frames, highlighting a symmetry that supports the principle's validity in quantum field contexts.

Contribution

It demonstrates that a radiative effect occurs for a stationary mirror observed by an accelerated detector in Rindler space, confirming a qualitative symmetry consistent with the equivalence principle.

Findings

Radiation observed from a stationary mirror in Rindler space.

Symmetry under interchange of accelerated and inertial frames.

Consistency with recent Unruh effect research.

Abstract

The equivalence principle is a perennial subject of controversy, especially in connection with radiation by a uniformly accelerated classical charge, or a freely falling charge observed by a supported detector. Recently, related issues have been raised in connection with the Unruh radiation associated with accelerated detectors (including two-level atoms and resonant cavities). A third type of system, very easy to analyze because of conformal invariance, is a two-dimensional scalar field interacting with perfectly reflecting boundaries (mirrors). After reviewing the issues for atoms and cavities, we investigate a stationary mirror from the point of view of an accelerated detector in "Rindler space". In keeping with the conclusions of earlier authors about the electromagnetic problem, we find that a radiative effect is indeed observed; from an inertial point of view, the process arises from a collision of the negative vacuum energy of Rindler space with the mirror. There is a qualitative symmetry under interchange of accelerated and inertial subsystems (a vindication of the equivalence principle), but it hinges on the accelerated detector's being initially in its own "Rindler vacuum". This observation is consistent with the recent work on the Unruh problem.