Who witnesses The Witness? Finding witnesses in The Witness is hard and sometimes impossible

TL;DR

This paper investigates the computational complexity of various puzzle types in The Witness, showing many are NP-complete or harder, and provides a polynomial-time solution for specific clues.

Contribution

It classifies the complexity of different puzzle constraints in The Witness and introduces a polynomial-time algorithm for monomino clues.

Findings

Most puzzle types are NP-complete for path finding.

Antibody clues make the problem $ ext{Sigma}_2$-complete.

Polynomial-time algorithm for monomino clues.

Abstract

We analyze the computational complexity of the many types of pencil-and-paper-style puzzles featured in the 2016 puzzle video game The Witness. In all puzzles, the goal is to draw a simple path in a rectangular grid graph from a start vertex to a destination vertex. The different puzzle types place different constraints on the path: preventing some edges from being visited (broken edges); forcing some edges or vertices to be visited (hexagons); forcing some cells to have certain numbers of incident path edges (triangles); or forcing the regions formed by the path to be partially monochromatic (squares), have exactly two special cells (stars), or be singly covered by given shapes (polyominoes) and/or negatively counting shapes (antipolyominoes). We show that any one of these clue types (except the first) is enough to make path finding NP-complete ("witnesses exist but are hard to find"), even for rectangular boards. Furthermore, we show that a final clue type (antibody), which necessarily "cancels" the effect of another clue in the same region, makes path finding $\Sigma_2$-complete ("witnesses do not exist"), even with a single antibody (combined with many anti/polyominoes), and the problem gets no harder with many antibodies. On the positive side, we give a polynomial-time algorithm for monomino clues, by reducing to hexagon clues on the boundary of the puzzle, even in the presence of broken edges, and solving "subset Hamiltonian path" for terminals on the boundary of an embedded planar graph in polynomial time.