Chemical Diversity in Three Massive Young Stellar Objects associated with 6.7 GHz CH$_{3}$OH Masers

TL;DR

This study investigates chemical diversity in three massive young stellar objects by observing various molecules, revealing differences in organic and carbon-chain molecule abundances that suggest diverse chemical environments around these objects.

Contribution

First detailed comparison of molecular ratios in multiple MYSOs, highlighting chemical diversity and differences between organic-rich hot cores and carbon-chain-rich lukewarm envelopes.

Findings

G28.28-0.36 has higher HC5N/CH3OH ratio than the others.

Organic-rich MYSOs show more complex organic molecules.

Carbon-chain-rich MYSOs have fewer complex organic lines.

Abstract

We have carried out observations in the 42$-$46 and 82$-$103 GHz bands with the Nobeyama 45-m radio telescope, and in the 338.2$-$339.2 and 348.45$-$349.45 GHz bands with the ASTE 10-m telescope toward three high-mass star-forming regions containing massive young stellar objects (MYSOs), G12.89+0.49, G16.86$-$2.16, and G28.28$-$0.36. We have detected HC$_{3}$N including its $^{13}$C and D isotopologues, CH$_{3}$OH, CH$_{3}$CCH, and several complex organic molecules (COMs). Combining our previous results of HC$_{5}$N in these sources, we compare the $N$(HC$_{5}$N)/$N$(CH$_{3}$OH) ratios in the three observed sources. The ratio in G28.28$-$0.36 is derived to be $0.091^{+0.109}_{-0.039}$, which is higher than that in G12.89+0.49 by one order of magnitude, and that in G16.86$-$2.16 by a factor of $\sim 5$. We investigate the relationship between the $N$(HC$_{5}$N)/$N$(CH$_{3}$OH) ratio and the $N$(CH$_{3}$CCH)/$N$(CH$_{3}$OH) ratio. The relationships of the two column density ratios in G28.28$-$0.36 and G16.86$-$2.16 are similar to each other, while HC$_{5}$N is less abundant when compared to CH$_{3}$CCH in G12.89+0.49. These results imply a chemical diversity in the lukewarm ($T \sim 20-30$ K) envelope around MYSOs. Besides, several spectral lines from complex organic molecules, including very-high-excitation energy lines, have been detected toward G12.89+0.49, while the line density is significantly low in G28.28$-$0.36. These results suggest that organic-poor MYSOs are surrounded by a carbon-chain-rich lukewarm envelope (G28.28$-$0.36), while organic-rich MYSOs, namely hot cores, are surrounded by a CH$_{3}$OH-rich lukewarm envelope (G12.89+0.49 and G16.86$-$2.16).