Analysis of CSAT performance in Wi-Fi and LTE-U Coexistence

TL;DR

This paper analyzes how LTE-U's high duty cycle impacts Wi-Fi coexistence, demonstrating that lower duty cycles improve fairness and proposing adjustments to LTE-U transmission strategies based on theoretical and experimental results.

Contribution

It provides a combined theoretical and experimental analysis of LTE-U's CSAT mechanism, highlighting the need to limit duty cycles for fair Wi-Fi coexistence.

Findings

High LTE-U duty cycle causes Wi-Fi association delays

Lower duty cycles improve Wi-Fi coexistence fairness

Experimental results confirm theoretical analysis

Abstract

In this paper, we study energy-based Carrier Sense Adaptive Transmission (CSAT) for use with LTE-U and investigate the performance in Wi-Fi/LTE-U coexistence using theoretical analysis and experimental verification using NI USRPs. According to the LTE-U forum specification, if an LTE-U base station (BS) finds a vacant channel, it can transmit for up to 20 ms and turn OFF its transmission for only 1 ms, resulting in a maximum duty cycle of 95%. In a dense deployment of LTE-U and Wi-Fi, it is very likely that a Wi-Fi access point (AP) will wish to use the same channel. It will start transmission by trying to transmit association packets (using carrier sense multiple access with collision avoidance (CSMA/CA)) through the 1 ms LTE-U OFF duration. Since this duration is very small, it leads to increased association packet drops and thus delays the Wi-Fi association process. Once LTE-U, using CSAT, detects Wi-Fi, it should scale back the duty cycle to 50%. We demonstrate in this paper, using an experimental platform as well as theoretical analysis, that if LTE-U is using a 95% duty cycle, energy based CSAT will take a much longer time to scale back the duty cycle due to the beacon drops and delays in the reception. Hence, in order to maintain association fairness with Wi-Fi, we propose that a LTE-U BS should not transmit at maximum duty cycles (95%), even if the channel is sensed to be vacant.