Proposal for a micromagnetic standard problem for materials with Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction

TL;DR

This paper proposes a standardized set of micromagnetic simulation problems involving Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction to benchmark and validate different computational tools for studying skyrmions and related magnetic phenomena.

Contribution

It introduces a comprehensive sequence of computational problems for DMI materials, enabling consistent testing and validation of micromagnetic simulation software.

Findings

Provides well-defined test problems for 1D, 2D, and 3D domains.

Includes validation cases for spin wave dynamics and skyrmion formation.

Facilitates benchmarking of micromagnetic simulation packages.

Abstract

Understanding the role of the Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction (DMI) for the formation of helimagnetic order, as well as the emergence of skyrmions in magnetic systems that lack inversion symmetry, has found increasing interest due to the significant potential for novel spin based technologies. Candidate materials to host skyrmions include those belonging to the B20 group such as FeGe, known for stabilising Bloch-like skyrmions, interfacial systems such as cobalt multilayers or Pd/Fe bilayers on top of Ir(111), known for stabilising N\'eel-like skyrmions, and, recently, alloys with a crystallographic symmetry where anti-skyrmions are stabilised. Micromagnetic simulations have become a standard approach to aid the design and optimisation of spintronic and magnetic nanodevices and are also applied to the modelling of device applications which make use of skyrmions. Several public domain micromagnetic simulation packages such as OOMMF, MuMax3 and Fidimag already offer implementations of different DMI terms. It is therefore highly desirable to propose a so-called micromagnetic standard problem that would allow one to benchmark and test the different software packages in a similar way as is done for ferromagnetic materials without DMI. Here, we provide a sequence of well-defined and increasingly complex computational problems for magnetic materials with DMI. Our test problems include 1D, 2D and 3D domains, spin wave dynamics in the presence of DMI, and validation of the analytical and numerical solutions including uniform magnetisation, edge tilting, spin waves and skyrmion formation. This set of problems can be used by developers and users of new micromagnetic simulation codes for testing and validation and hence establishing scientific credibility.