A Role for Turbulence in Circumgalactic Precipitation

TL;DR

This paper proposes a turbulence-driven model for the critical cooling time to freefall time ratio that triggers condensation in galaxy atmospheres, linking turbulence, gravity waves, and feedback to explain observed phenomena.

Contribution

It introduces a heuristic model connecting turbulence and gravity-wave oscillations to the critical t_cool/t_ff ratio for condensation in galaxy clusters.

Findings

Turbulence can drive gravity-wave oscillations into condensation when 10 < t_cool/t_ff < 20.

The observed gas-phase velocity dispersion aligns with the model's predictions for turbulence levels.

The system can reach a self-regulated equilibrium balancing feedback, turbulence, and cooling.

Abstract

Abundant observational evidence indicates that the cooling time t_cool of the hot ambient medium pervading a massive galaxy does not drop much below 10 times the freefall time t_ff at any radius. Theoretical models have accounted for this finding by hypothesizing that cold clouds start to condense out of the ambient medium when t_cool/t_ff < 10 and fuel a strong black-hole feedback response that reheats the ambient gas, but those models have not yet been able to provide a simple explanation for the origin of the critical t_cool/t_ff ratio. This paper explores a heuristic model for condensation that links the critical ratio to turbulent driving of gravity-wave oscillations. In the linear regime, internal gravity waves are thermally unstable in a thermally balanced medium. Buoyancy oscillations in a balanced medium with t_cool/t_ff therefore grow until they saturate without condensing at an amplitude that depends on t_cool/t_ff. However, in a medium with 10 < t_cool/t_ff < 20, turbulence with a velocity dispersion roughly half the galaxy's stellar velocity dispersion can drive those oscillations into condensation. Intriguingly, this is indeed the gas-phase velocity dispersion observed among galaxy-cluster cores that contain multiphase gas. It is therefore possible that both the critical t_cool/t_ff ratio for condensation of ambient gas and the level of turbulence in that gas are determined by coupling between condensation, feedback, and turbulence. Such a system can converge to a well-regulated equilibrium state, as long as the fraction of feedback energy that goes into turbulence is significantly less than the fraction that goes more directly into heat.