Nonuniform Sampling for Random Signals Bandlimited in the Linear Canonical Transform Domain
Haiye Huo, Wenchang Sun

TL;DR
This paper investigates nonuniform sampling of random signals bandlimited in the linear canonical transform domain, proposing an approximate recovery method and analyzing the mean square error, supported by simulations.
Contribution
It introduces a novel approach linking nonuniform sampling in the LCT domain to uniform sampling via second order statistics, with an approximate recovery method and error analysis.
Findings
Nonuniform sampling in LCT domain is equivalent to uniform sampling in second order statistics.
Proposed an approximate recovery method for nonuniform sampled signals.
Validated theoretical results through simulations.
Abstract
In this paper, we mainly investigate the nonuniform sampling for random signals which are bandlimited in the linear canonical transform (LCT) domain. We show that the nonuniform sampling for a random signal bandlimited in the LCT domain is equal to the uniform sampling in the sense of second order statistic characters after a pre-filter in the LCT domain. Moreover, we propose an approximate recovery approach for nonuniform sampling of random signals bandlimited in the LCT domain. Furthermore, we study the mean square error of the nonuniform sampling. Finally, we do some simulations to verify the correctness of our theoretical results.
Peer Reviews
No public reviews on file for this paper yet. If you reviewed it on a platform where reviews are public (OpenReview, ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML), you can paste yours below so the community can read it here.
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsMathematical Analysis and Transform Methods · Image and Signal Denoising Methods · Sparse and Compressive Sensing Techniques
Nonuniform Sampling for Random Signals Bandlimited in the Linear Canonical Transform Domain††thanks: This work was partially supported by the
National Natural Science Foundation of China (11525104, 11531013 and 11371200).
Haiye Huoa, Wenchang Sunb
a Department of Mathematics, School of Science, Nanchang University,
Nanchang 330031, Jiangxi, China
b School of Mathematical Sciences and LPMC, Nankai University,
Tianjin 300071, China
Emails: [email protected]; [email protected]
Abstract. In this paper, we mainly investigate the nonuniform sampling for random signals which are bandlimited in the linear canonical transform (LCT) domain. We show that the nonuniform sampling for a random signal bandlimited in the LCT domain is equal to the uniform sampling in the sense of second order statistic characters after a pre-filter in the LCT domain. Moreover, we propose an approximate recovery approach for nonuniform sampling of random signals bandlimited in the LCT domain. Furthermore, we study the mean square error of the nonuniform sampling. Finally, we do some simulations to verify the correctness of our theoretical results.
Keywords. Nonuniform sampling; Linear canonical transform; Random signals; Approximate reconstruction; Sinc interpolation
1 Introduction
Sampling is very fundamental in signal processing, as it provides an effective way to connect the analogue signals and digital signals. Since Shannon [18] introduced the concept of sampling theorem in 1949, the sampling theorem has been widely studied in various academic fields. In particular, uniform sampling theorems for deterministic signals or random signals, which are bandlimited in the Fourier domain, fractional Fourier transform domain, or linear canonical transform (LCT) domain, have been intensely studied in literatures [4, 5, 10, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 24, 27, 28, 29, 30, 34].
In practice, we might only obtain nonuniform samples, for instance, in the areas of geophysics, biomedical imaging, or communication theory [8, 12, 17]. Therefore, nonuniform sampling has aroused much more attention on the theoretical and practical sides in the literature. There are many kinds of approaches for recovering the original signals from their nonuniform samples. For example, Yao and Thomas [32] derived the reconstruction formula for bandlimited signals from their nonuniform samples by using the Lagrange interpolation functions. However, since the Lagrange interpolation functions often have distinct formats at different sampling times, it is very complicated to recover the bandlimited signals by utilizing Lagrange interpolation functions. Many other approaches have been presented to solve this problem. Time-warping technique was used in [15] for recovering bandlimited signals from their jittered samples. In [16], the author made some revision on traditional Lagrange interpolation functions, in order to improve the accuracy of recovering bandlimited signals from their nonuniform samples. Due to the perfect recovery of bandlimited signals from their nonuniform samples with sinc interpolation, Maymon and Oppenheim [14] proposed a class of approximate recovery approaches for bandlimited signals from their nonuniform samples by utilizing sinc interpolation functions. Furthermore, Xu, Zhang and Tao [31] generalized the results mentioned in [14] from traditional Fourier domain to fractional Fourier transform domain. In order to learn more information on nonuniform sampling, we refer the readers to [1, 3, 6, 9, 13, 23, 25, 33].
For random signals which are bandlimited in the LCT domain, there exist few results on sampling theorems. In [10], based on the framework of LCT auto-correlation function and power spectral density, we investigated the uniform sampling theorem and multichannel sampling theorem for random signals which are bandlimited in LCT domain. In this paper, we derive the relationship between the LCT auto-power spectral densities of the inputs and outputs. In addition, we study the nonuniform sampling for random signals bandlimited in the LCT domain and give an approximate recovery approach with sinc interpolation functions. Moreover, we investigate the error estimate of nonuniform sampling for random signals bandlimited in the LCT domain in the mean square sense. Finally, some simulations are carried out to illustrate the effectiveness of our methods.
The rest of the paper is presented as follows. In Section 2, we first introduce the concepts of the LCT, the LCT correlation function, and the LCT power spectral density. Then, we show the connection between the LCT auto-power spectral density of the inputs and outputs. In Section 3, we study the nonuniform sampling, its approximate recovery method, the corresponding reconstruction error for random signals bandlimited in the LCT domain in the mean square sense. Moreover, we analyze the performances of our theoretical results by simulation. In Section 4, we conclude the paper.
2 Preliminaries
2.1 The Linear Canonical Transform
Definition 2.1**.**
The LCT of a signal is denoted by [10]
[TABLE]
where A=\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}a&b\\ c&d\\ \end{array}\right), and parameters satisfy .
Since the LCT is a Chirp multiplication operator when , we assume without loss of the generality that in the rest of the paper. From (1), we can easily derive the connection between the LCT and the Fourier transform as follows:
[TABLE]
where the Fourier transform of is defined by
[TABLE]
2.2 The LCT Power Spectral Density
In this paper, we consider a special class of random signals that is wide sense stationary. Given a probability space , a stochastic process is called stationary in a wide sense, if its mean is zero, its second moment is finite, and its auto-correlation function
[TABLE]
is independent of , where denotes mathematical expectation, and stands for the complex conjugate of . Two stochastic processes and are said to be jointly stationary in a wide sense, if and are both wide sense stationary, and their cross-correlation function
[TABLE]
is independent of .
Next, we introduce the LCT auto-correlation function, the LCT cross-correlation function, the LCT auto-power spectral density and the LCT cross-power spectral density as follows.
Definition 2.2**.**
Given random signals and , the LCT auto-correlation function of is defined by
[TABLE]
and the LCT cross-correlation function of and is defined by
[TABLE]
One can see that if is stationary, that is,
[TABLE]
where then the function also depends only on . In fact,
[TABLE]
Definition 2.3**.**
Given random signals and , and two parameters A=\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}a&b\\ c&d\\ \end{array}\right), A^{\prime}=\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}a&-b\\ -c&d\\ \end{array}\right). The LCT auto-power spectral density of is defined by
[TABLE]
and the LCT cross-power spectral density of and is defined by
[TABLE]
where
[TABLE]
and
[TABLE]
It follows from (1) and (10) that
[TABLE]
In [10, 7], a model of LCT multiplicative filter has been introduced as in Fig. 1, where , , and the output function is given by
[TABLE]
With the LCT multiplicative filter described in Fig. 1, we can obtain the relationship between the LCT auto-power spectral density and cross-power spectral density .
Proposition 2.4**.**
[10, Theorem 2.3]** Let random signals and be the input and output of the LCT multiplicative filter, and the transfer function satisfy
[TABLE]
Then,
[TABLE]
Similarly, we can get the connection between and as follows.
Theorem 2.5**.**
Let random signals and be the input and output of the LCT multiplicative filter, and the transfer function satisfy
[TABLE]
Then,
[TABLE]
Proof.
By (15), we have
[TABLE]
Using the convolution theorem ([7, Theorem 1]), we can rewrite (20) as
[TABLE]
Thus,
[TABLE]
where . Combining (13) and (22), we get
[TABLE]
Therefore, we obtain
[TABLE]
Substituting (10) and (11) into (24), we have
[TABLE]
It follows from (17) that
[TABLE]
This completes the proof. ∎
3 Nonuniform Sampling and Error Estimate for Random Signals Bandlimited in the LCT Domain
In this section, we study the nonuniform sampling and error estimate for random signals which are bandlimited in the LCT domain. First, we introduce the definition.
Definition 3.1**.**
[10]** We call a random signal bandlimited in the LCT domain, if its LCT power spectral density satisfies
[TABLE]
where is the bandwidth.
Before stating our main results, we present a lemma that is useful in the following.
Lemma 3.2**.**
Assume that a random signal is bandlimited in the LCT domain with bandwidth , and is a wide sense stationary process. Then, is bandlimited in the Fourier domain with bandwidth
Proof.
Since is stationary in a wide sense, it follows from (9) and (10) that
[TABLE]
Note that
[TABLE]
We have
[TABLE]
This completes the proof. ∎
3.1 Nonuniform Sampling
First, we restate a nonuniform sampling theorem for deterministic signals which are bandlimited in the LCT domain, as mentioned in [23].
Proposition 3.3**.**
[23, Theorem 4]** Suppose that a deterministic signal is bandlimited in the LCT domain with bandwidth . If
[TABLE]
then the function can be perfectly recovered by its samples with the following formula,
[TABLE]
where
[TABLE]
, and is the derivative of .
It is known that Lagrange interpolation functions often have distinct formats at different sampling times. Hence it is very complicated to recover signals by using Proposition 3.3. In this paper, we give another recovery approach instead. We begin with a nonuniform sampling model [31] as in Fig. 2, where is the sampling sequence of a random signal , and is the sequence of sampling points. We assume that , where is the average sampling interval, and is a sequence of independent identically distributed (i.i.d.) random variables with zero mean in the interval . This nonuniform sampling model is also called jitter sampling. For jitter sampling, the sampling noise is introduced to the expected sampling time, i.e., with and . For example, the time base jitter of a GHz sampling oscilloscope is identified to have standard deviation ps, that is, the actual measurement time is corrupted by zero-mean Gaussian noise [26]. The jittered samples often occur in biomedical devices and A/D converters due to the internal clock imperfections [2, 11].
Next we show that in the sense of second order statistic characters, nonuniform sampling is identical to uniform sampling after a pre-filter.
Theorem 3.4**.**
Assume that a random signal is bandlimited in the LCT domain with bandwidth , and is a wide sense stationary process. Then, in the sense of second order statistic characters, the nonuniform sampling of is identical to the uniform sampling after a LCT filter established in Fig. 3, i.e.,
[TABLE]
where is the average sampling interval, is the sampling point, is an additive noise with zero mean and is independent of , and the LCT auto-power spectral density of is Here, , where denotes the characteristic function of .
Proof.
Since is a wide sense stationary process, the nonuniform sampling can be described as in Fig 4. By the design of LCT filter in Fig 3, we have
[TABLE]
Since is an additive noise with zero mean and is independent of , the LCT auto-correlation function of is identical to . Thus, combining (14) and (32), we have
[TABLE]
Hence
[TABLE]
Since and are two random variables, by (14), we obtain
[TABLE]
Combining (9) and (14), we have
[TABLE]
Let and be the probability density function of . Note that and are independent and have identical distributions. Let be their common probability density function. Then we have
[TABLE]
where denote as the convolution operator. Hence
[TABLE]
where
[TABLE]
Substituting (38) into (36), we get
[TABLE]
By setting in (34), we get (39). Hence, the auto-correlation function of in Fig. 4 is equal to that of the output in Fig. 3. Therefore, the nonuniform sampling is identical to the uniform sampling in Fig. 4, in the sense of second order statistic characters. This completes the proof. ∎
3.2 Approximate recovery approach
As we mention above, it is much easier to deal with uniform sampling than nonuniform sampling. Since sinc interpolation leads to exact recovery for uniform sampling, Maymon and Oppenheim [14] introduced a new approximate recovery formula of nonuniform sampling for a random signal bandlimited in Fourier domain by utilizing sinc interpolation function. The approximate recovery formula can be represented as follows:
[TABLE]
where s(t)={\rm{sinc}}\big{(}\frac{\pi t}{T_{N}}\big{)}, is the bandwidth of , . Here, is not required to be identical to the original sampling points . But, if the original random signal is not bandlimited in the Fourier domain, the approximate recovery approach might not work. Motivated by [14], Xu, Zhang, and Tao [31] considered the case when the random signal is bandlimited in the fractional Fourier domain. Since LCT is a more general transform, which includes Fourier transform and fractional Fourier transform as its special cases, it is possible that a signal which is non-bandlimited in the Fourier domain or the fractional Fourier domain, is bandlimited in the LCT domain. So, it is necessary to investigate the corresponding approximate recovery result for random signal bandlimited in the LCT domain.
Theorem 3.5**.**
Assume that random a signal is bandlimited in the LCT domain with bandwidth , and is a wide sense stationary process. Then can be approximated from its nonuniform samples by utilizing the sinc interpolation function,
[TABLE]
where h_{2}(t)={\rm{sinc}}\big{(}\frac{u_{r}t}{b}\big{)}, is the uniform sampling interval, is the Nyquist sampling interval, , and is not necessarily equal to .
Proof.
From Lemma 3.2, we know that is bandlimited in the Fourier domain with bandwidth By (40), we have
[TABLE]
Substituting and into (42), we obtain (41), which completes the proof. ∎
From Theorem 3.5 we know that the approximate recovery approach for random signals which are bandlimited in the LCT domain, can be expressed as the model presented in Fig. 5.
3.3 Error estimate of reconstruction for random signals
In this subsection, we study the reconstruction error in the mean square sense by considering the sampling and reconstruction procedures as the system whose frequency response is dependent on the probability density function of the perturbations. It follows from Theorem 3.4 that, if the average sampling interval is greater than the Nyquist sampling interval , then the model presented in Fig. 6 is identical to the procedure, which includes the nonuniform sampling mentioned in subsection 3.1, and the approximate reconstruction approach by using sinc interpolation function described in Fig. 5, in the sense of second order statistic characters.
Theorem 3.6**.**
Assume that a random signal is bandlimited in the LCT domain with bandwidth , is the approximation of obtained in Fig. 6, and is a wide sense stationary process. Let the frequency response of the filter be the joint characteristic function of the random variables and , i.e., . And let be an additive noise with zero mean, which is uncorrelated with and has the power spectral density
[TABLE]
Then the model described in Fig. 6 is identical to the procedure, which includes the nonuniform sampling mentioned in subsection 3.1 and the approximate reconstruction approach by utilizing sinc interpolation function represented in Fig. 5, in the sense of second order statistic characters. Furthermore, we have
[TABLE]
Proof.
By Theorem 3.5, we have
[TABLE]
where h_{2}(t)={\rm{sinc}}\big{(}\frac{u_{r}}{b}t\big{)}. Thus, we can get the auto-correlation function of as follows:
[TABLE]
Next, we use two steps to compute . Note that
[TABLE]
and
[TABLE]
We obtain
[TABLE]
where we use the fact that in the last step.
Similarly, we have
[TABLE]
Combining (48) and (49), we obtain
[TABLE]
Similarly, we can obtain the cross-correlation function of and as follows,
[TABLE]
Therefore, we have
[TABLE]
and
[TABLE]
Hence, the first term in (52) is the power spectral density of in Fig. 6. Substituting (27) into (43), we have
[TABLE]
Thus, the second term \frac{T}{2\pi}\Big{(}\int_{-\frac{u_{r}}{b}}^{\frac{u_{r}}{b}}P_{\tilde{x}\tilde{x}}(u_{1})[1-|\phi_{\xi\zeta}(u_{1},-u)|^{2}]{\rm{d}}u_{1}\Big{)} in (52) is identical to the power spectral density of . Consequently, the model described in Fig. 6 is equal to the procedure, which includes the nonuniform sampling mentioned in subsection 3.1 and the approximate reconstruction approach by utilizing sinc interpolation function represented in Fig. 5, in the sense of second order statistic characters.
Next, we estimate the error . Let . Combining (27) and (52), we get
[TABLE]
Similarly, we obtain
[TABLE]
Hence, the LCT auto-power spectral density of the reconstruction error in Fig. 6 is
[TABLE]
Therefore, it follows from (9) and (14) that
[TABLE]
This completes the proof. ∎
Note that the reconstruction error is related to the LCT auto-correlation power spectral density of the random signal and the joint characteristic function of two random variables and . In particular, when and are constants and both are equal to zeros, i.e., the nonuniform sampling studied in this paper reduces to uniform sampling, we have from Theorem 3.6. Therefore the result of uniform sampling proposed in [10, Theorem 3.4] is a special case of Theorems 3.5 and 3.6 in this paper.
On the other hand, the LCT includes many widely used linear transforms as special cases. For example, by setting A=\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}\cos\theta&\sin\theta\\ -\sin\theta&\cos\theta\\ \end{array}\right) with in (1), the LCT of becomes the fractional Fourier transform of with angle . In this case, our results coincide with those in [31], and in particular, when and are constants and equal to zeros, our results coincide with the uniform sampling results in [24]. Furthermore, by setting A=\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}0&1\\ -1&0\\ \end{array}\right), the LCT of becomes the Fourier transform of multiplied by a constant . In this case, our results coincide with those in [14].
3.4 Simulations
In this subsection, we consider a random signal , where follows the standard Gaussian distribution. It is easy to verify that is wide sense stationary, and is approximately bandlimited with bandwidth Hz in the LCT domain with parameter A=\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}a&b\\ c&d\\ \end{array}\right)=\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}3&1/\pi\\ \pi&2/3\\ \end{array}\right). Let . First, the approximate signal recovery results based on (41) for one realization of are respectively shown in Fig. 7 in terms of two different nonuniform sampling models. Let follow the uniform distribution in the interval and integer take a value from [math] to . Then, for each , , we implement realizations of and estimate the mean square error of the reconstruction in terms of four different nonuniform sampling models as shown in Fig. 8. One can see from Fig. 8 that the reconstruction from the nonuniform sampling with is preferable. In fact, the reconstruction is an approximate solution, and we cannot claim which sampling model is the best in general. However, according to (3.6) in Theorem 3.6, a lower mean square error of the reconstruction might be obtained by choosing a proper joint characteristic function of and .
4 Conclusion
In this paper, we mainly discuss the nonuniform sampling for random signals, which are bandlimited in the LCT domain. At the beginning, based on the concepts of the LCT correlation function and power spectral density, we get the connection between the LCT auto-power spectral density of the inputs and outputs. Moreover, we show that nonuniform sampling for random signals bandlimited in the LCT domain can be identical to uniform sampling after a pre-filter in the sense of second order statistic characters. Furthermore, we derive an approximate reconstruction formula for random signals bandlimited in LCT domain from their nonuniform samples, by utilizing the sinc interpolation functions. Finally, we investigate the error between the original random signal and its approximation in the mean square sense, and verify the performances of our theoretical results by numerical simulation.
The reference list from the paper itself. Each links out to its DOI / PubMed record.
- 1[1] Aldroubi, A., Gröchenig, K.: ‘Nonuniform sampling and reconstruction in shift-invariant spaces’, SIAM Review , 2001, 43 , (4), pp. 585–620
- 2[2] Amirtharajah, R., Collier, J., Siebert, J., Zhou, B., Chandrakasan, A.: ‘DS Ps for engery harvesting sensors: applications and architectures’, IEEE Pervasive Computing , 2005, 4 , (3), pp. 72–79
- 3[3] Balakrishnan, A.V.: ‘On the problem of time jitter in sampling’, IRE Trans Inform Theory , 1962, 8 , (3), pp. 226–236
- 4[4] Bhandari, A., Marziliano, P.: ‘Sampling and reconstruction of sparse signals in fractional Fourier domain’, IEEE Signal Process Lett , 2010, 17 , (3), pp. 221–224
- 5[5] Brown, J.L., Jr: ‘On mean-square aliasing error in the cardinal series expansion of random processes’, IEEE Trans Inform Theory , 1978, 24 , (2), pp. 254–256
- 6[6] Chen, Y., Goldsmith, A.J., Eldar, Y.C.: ‘Channel capacity under sub-nyquist nonuniform sampling’, IEEE Trans Inform Theory , 2014, 60 , (8), pp. 4739–4756
- 7[7] Deng, B., Tao, R., Wang, Y.: ‘Convolution theorems for the linear canonical transform and their applications’, Sci China, Ser F: Inform Sci , 2006, 49 , (5), pp. 592–603
- 8[8] Eng, F.: ‘Nonuniform sampling in statistical signal processing’ (Ph.D. Thesis, Linkoping University, Department of Electrical Engineering, 2007)
