Optimal Single Sample Tests for Structured versus Unstructured Network Data

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new single-sample testing method to distinguish between mean field and structured Gibbs distributions, effective at high temperatures and without prior parameter knowledge, with proven optimality.

Contribution

It develops a general, optimal testing approach applicable to Ising and exponential random graph models based on global aggregation of data.

Findings

The test can distinguish hypotheses with high probability above a certain temperature threshold.

The method is optimal; below the threshold, no test can succeed.

It works effectively even at very high temperatures by aggregating global information.

Abstract

We study the problem of testing, using only a single sample, between mean field distributions (like Curie-Weiss, Erd\H{o}s-R\'enyi) and structured Gibbs distributions (like Ising model on sparse graphs and Exponential Random Graphs). Our goal is to test without knowing the parameter values of the underlying models: only the \emph{structure} of dependencies is known. We develop a new approach that applies to both the Ising and Exponential Random Graph settings based on a general and natural statistical test. The test can distinguish the hypotheses with high probability above a certain threshold in the (inverse) temperature parameter, and is optimal in that below the threshold no test can distinguish the hypotheses. The thresholds do not correspond to the presence of long-range order in the models. By aggregating information at a global scale, our test works even at very high temperatures. The proofs are based on distributional approximation and sharp concentration of quadratic forms, when restricted to Hamming spheres. The restriction to Hamming spheres is necessary, since otherwise any scalar statistic is useless without explicit knowledge of the temperature parameter. At the same time, this restriction radically changes the behavior of the functions under consideration, resulting in a much smaller variance than in the independent setting; this makes it hard to directly apply standard methods (i.e., Stein's method) for concentration of weakly dependent variables. Instead, we carry out an additional tensorization argument using a Markov chain that respects the symmetry of the Hamming sphere.