Random Switching for High Performance DC-DC Power Converters

TL;DR

This paper explores Random Switching (RS) in high-performance DC-DC converters, demonstrating its advantages in spectral shaping, efficiency, and control simplicity over traditional PWM methods.

Contribution

It introduces RS as an optimal, probabilistic switching strategy that separates DC behavior from spectral content, enabling better harmonic control without external filters.

Findings

RS achieves lower switching losses than other RPWM methods.

Pulse probability distributions shape the PSD effectively.

Cuk's model applies directly to RS, simplifying analysis.

Abstract

Random Pulse Width Modulation (RPWM) has been successfully applied in power electronics for nearly 30 years. The effects of the various possible RPWM strategies on the Power Spectral Density have been thoroughly studied. Despite the effectiveness of RPWM in spreading harmonic content, an appeal is consistently made to maintain the textbook Pulse Width Modulation scheme 'on average'. Random Switching (RS) does away with this notion and probabilistically operates the switch. In addition to fulfilling several optimality conditions, including being the only viable switching strategy at the theoretical limit of performance and having lower switching losses than any other RPWM; RS allows for design of the DC behaviour separately from that of the PSD. The pulse amplitude probability affects the DC and total PSD. The first and second moment of the pulse length probability distribution affects the shape of the envelope of the noise of the PSD. The minimum pulse length acts like a selective harmonic filter. The PSD can therefore be shaped without external filtering by changing these probabilities. Gaussian and Huffman pulse length probabilities are shown to be good choices depending on whether real-time PSD control or spectrum usage are the design goal. In addition, it is shown that C\'uk's state space averaging model applies to RS, with $D \to p$, hence no new tools are needed to understand the low frequency behavior or control performance. A benefit of closed loop random switching is that no filtering of the controlled variable is required. Randomly responding in a biased manner dependent on the error is hence shown to be useful. There are several good reasons to consider RS for high performance applications.