Ions at hydrophobic interfaces

TL;DR

This paper investigates the mechanisms of anionic adsorption at hydrophobic interfaces, emphasizing the role of cavitational energy and electrostatic surface potential, and critiques current water models for their inaccuracies.

Contribution

It argues that the electrostatic surface potential in classical water models is artificial and incompatible with polarizable ionic force fields, proposing the development of improved models.

Findings

Polarizable force fields predict strong anionic adsorption due to electrostatic potential.

Experimental surface tension data contradict large adsorption predictions.

Current point charge water models are incompatible with polarizable ionic models.

Abstract

We argue that the kosmotropes remain strongly hydrated in the vicinity of a hydrophobic surface, while the chaotropes lose their hydration shell and can become adsorbed to the interface. The mechanism of adsorption is still a subject of debate. We argue that there are two driving forces for anionic adsorption: the hydrophobic cavitational energy and the interfacial electrostatic surface potential of water. While the cavitational contribution to ionic adsorption is now well accepted, the role of the electrostatic surface potential is much less clear. The difficulty is that even the sign of this potential is a subject of debate, with the ab initio and the classical force field simulations predicting electrostatic surface potentials of opposite sign. In this paper, we will argue that the strong anionic adsorption found in the polarizable force field simulations is the result of the artificial electrostatic surface potential present in the classical water models. We will show that if the adsorption of anions were as large as predicted by the polarizable force field simulations, the excess surface tension of the NaI solution would be strongly negative, contrary to the experimental measurements. While the large polarizability of heavy halides is a fundamental property and must be included in realistic modeling of the electrolyte solutions, we argue that the point charge water models, studied so far, are incompatible with the polarizable ionic force fields when the translational symmetry is broken. The goal for the future should be the development of water models with very low electrostatic surface potential. We believe that such water models will be compatible with the polarizable force fields, which can then be used to study the interaction of ions with hydrophobic surfaces and proteins.