Paradoxical consequences of multipath coherence: perfect interaction-free measurements

TL;DR

This paper investigates the fundamental limits of interaction-free measurements in quantum mechanics and generalized theories, revealing a trade-off that prevents perfect measurements and proposing that their absence is a universal physical principle.

Contribution

It formalizes the trade-off relation for interaction-free measurements, extends the analysis to generalized models like density cubes, and constructs explicit examples of perfect measurements, challenging previous assumptions.

Findings

Interaction-free measurements cannot be perfect in quantum mechanics.

A trade-off relation limits the probability of activation and inconclusiveness.

Models with multipath coherence can, in principle, allow perfect interaction-free measurements.

Abstract

Quantum coherence can be used to infer the presence of a detector without triggering it. Here we point out that, according to quantum mechanics, such interaction-free measurements cannot be perfect, i.e., in a single-shot experiment one has strictly positive probability to activate the detector. We formalize the extent to which such measurements are forbidden by deriving a trade-off relation between the probability of activation and the probability of an inconclusive interaction-free measurement. Our description of interaction-free measurements is theory independent and allows derivations of similar relations in models generalizing quantum mechanics. We provide the trade-off for the density cube formalism, which extends the quantum model by permitting coherence between more than two paths. The trade-off obtained hints at the possibility of perfect interaction-free measurements and indeed we construct their explicit examples. Such measurements open up a paradoxical possibility where we can learn by means of interference about the presence of an object in a given location without ever detecting a probing particle in that location. We therefore propose that absence of perfect interaction-free measurement is a natural postulate expected to hold in all physical theories. As shown, it holds in quantum mechanics and excludes the models with multipath coherence.