Challenges in Modelling and Simulation of Turbulent Flows with Spatially-Developing Coherent Structures

TL;DR

This paper investigates the challenges in scale-resolving simulations of turbulent wake flows with coherent structures, emphasizing the importance of resolution, flow mechanisms, and stochastic modeling to accurately capture flow features.

Contribution

It introduces a quantitative criterion for resolving coherent structures in turbulent flows, based on Kelvin-Helmholtz instability and strain-rate ratios, guiding better simulation practices.

Findings

Coherent structures are generated by Kelvin-Helmholtz instability.

Resolution must exceed critical Reynolds number for accurate structure capture.

Strain-rate ratio provides a quantitative measure for unresolved turbulence.

Abstract

The objective of this work is to investigate the challenges encountered in Scale-Resolving Simulations (SRS's) of turbulent wake flows driven by spatially-developing coherent structures. SRS's of practical interest are expressly intended for efficiently computing such flows by resolving only the most important features of the coherent structures and modelling the remainder as stochastic field. The success of SRS methods depends upon three important factors: i) ability to identify key flow mechanisms responsible for the generation of coherent structures; ii) determine the optimum range of resolution required to adequately capture key elements of coherent structures; and iii) ensure that the modelled part is comprised nearly exclusively of fully-developed stochastic turbulence. This study considers the canonical case of the flow around a circular cylinder to address these three key issues. It is first demonstrated using experimental evidence that the vortex-shedding instability and flow-structure development involves four important stages. A series of SRS computations of progressively increasing resolution are performed. An a priori basis for locating the origin of the coherent structures development is proposed and examined. The criterion is based on the fact that the coherent structures are generated by the Kelvin-Helmholtz (KH) instability. The most important finding is that the key aspects of coherent structures can be resolved only if the effective computational Reynolds number exceeds the critical value of the KH instability in laminar flows. Finally, a quantitative criterion assessing the nature of the unresolved field based on the strain-rate ratio of mean and unresolved fields is examined. The two proposed conditions and underlying rationale offer a quantitative basis for develop "good practice" guidelines for SRS of complex turbulent wake flows with coherent structures.