Why lot: How sortition came to help representative democracy

TL;DR

This paper explores how incorporating randomly selected independent legislators into parliamentary systems can reduce factionalism and improve efficiency, using a new mathematical model to demonstrate potential benefits over traditional party-based legislatures.

Contribution

It introduces a novel mathematical model showing that adding independent legislators via sortition can enhance parliamentary efficiency and mitigate factionalism caused by party discipline.

Findings

Increasing independent legislators improves parliamentary efficiency.

Sortition helps balance party influence and reduce factional conflicts.

A model demonstrates optimal independent legislator proportion for best outcomes.

Abstract

In this paper we discuss the problems of modern representative democracy and we look at the selection of legislators by lot as a way to tame some of the drawbacks of that system. It is recalled at the beginning that resorting to sortition for the selection of public officers used to be a popular way of taming factionalism in public affairs. Factionalism is assumed to be detrimental to public affairs as public officers may favour their own faction (a tribe or a party) instead of pursuing the general interest. Moreover they tend to overinvest in strengthening their power, thus engaging in power struggles with opposing factions, unlikely to benefit society. In this respect we present a new mathematical model aiming at describing a more efficient parliament where sortition is brought to bear. It will be shown that starting from a parliament working with two parties (or coalitions), where the costs of representative democracy are quite apparent through the detrimental effects of party discipline, one can beneficially move towards a parliament where independent legislators, randomly selected from the population of constituents, sit alongside elected members who belong to a party and are subjected to party discipline. The paper shows that increasing the number of independent legislators up to a point enhances the efficiency of the parliament and puts into check the factionalism likely to arise from party discipline.