Carbon cycling and habitability of Earth-size stagnant lid planets

TL;DR

This study models the thermal evolution and CO2 cycling of Earth-sized stagnant lid planets to identify conditions that sustain habitability without requiring plate tectonics, providing insights for exoplanet habitability assessments.

Contribution

It introduces a simplified model linking initial radiogenic heat, CO2 budget, and habitability duration, challenging the necessity of plate tectonics for long-term climate stability.

Findings

Planets with 100-250 TW radiogenic heating can remain habitable for 1-5 Gyrs.

Larger CO2 budgets lead to uninhabitably hot climates.

Smaller CO2 budgets cause global glaciation.

Abstract

Models of thermal evolution, crustal production, and CO$_2$ cycling are used to constrain the prospects for habitability of rocky planets, with Earth-like size and composition, in the stagnant lid regime. Specifically, we determine the conditions under which such planets can maintain rates of CO$_2$ degassing large enough to prevent global surface glaciation, but small enough so as not to exceed the upper limit on weathering rates provided by the supply of fresh rock, a situation which would lead to runaway atmospheric CO$_2$ accumulation and an inhospitably hot climate. The models show that stagnant lid planets with initial radiogenic heating rates of 100-250 TW, and with total CO$_2$ budgets ranging from $\sim 10^{-2} -1$ times Earth's estimated CO$_2$ budget, can maintain volcanic outgassing rates suitable for habitability for $\approx 1-5$ Gyrs; larger CO$_2$ budgets result in uninhabitably hot climates, while smaller budgets result in global glaciation. High radiogenic heat production rates favor habitability by sustaining volcanism and CO$_2$ outgassing longer. Thus, the results suggest that plate tectonics may not be required for establishing a long-term carbon cycle and maintaining a stable, habitable climate. The model is necessarily highly simplified, as the uncertainties with exoplanet thermal evolution and outgassing are large. Nevertheless, the results provide some first order guidance for future exoplanet missions, by predicting the age at which habitability becomes unlikely for a stagnant lid planet as a function of initial radiogenic heat budget. This prediction is powerful because both planet heat budget and age can potentially be constrained from stellar observations.