Balancing Speed and Quality in Online Learning to Rank for Information Retrieval

TL;DR

This paper introduces new models for Online Learning to Rank that balance the tradeoff between learning speed and ranking quality, enabling faster training without sacrificing final ranking performance.

Contribution

It proposes Sim-MGD, a fast ranking model based on document similarities, and C-MGD, a cascading approach that combines fast learning with high-quality convergence.

Findings

Sim-MGD converges rapidly, improving user experience.

C-MGD achieves fast learning with convergence comparable to state-of-the-art models.

The models open new avenues for designing OLTR systems without the speed-quality tradeoff.

Abstract

In Online Learning to Rank (OLTR) the aim is to find an optimal ranking model by interacting with users. When learning from user behavior, systems must interact with users while simultaneously learning from those interactions. Unlike other Learning to Rank (LTR) settings, existing research in this field has been limited to linear models. This is due to the speed-quality tradeoff that arises when selecting models: complex models are more expressive and can find the best rankings but need more user interactions to do so, a requirement that risks frustrating users during training. Conversely, simpler models can be optimized on fewer interactions and thus provide a better user experience, but they will converge towards suboptimal rankings. This tradeoff creates a deadlock, since novel models will not be able to improve either the user experience or the final convergence point, without sacrificing the other. Our contribution is twofold. First, we introduce a fast OLTR model called Sim-MGD that addresses the speed aspect of the speed-quality tradeoff. Sim-MGD ranks documents based on similarities with reference documents. It converges rapidly and, hence, gives a better user experience but it does not converge towards the optimal rankings. Second, we contribute Cascading Multileave Gradient Descent (C-MGD) for OLTR that directly addresses the speed-quality tradeoff by using a cascade that enables combinations of the best of two worlds: fast learning and high quality final convergence. C-MGD can provide the better user experience of Sim-MGD while maintaining the same convergence as the state-of-the-art MGD model. This opens the door for future work to design new models for OLTR without having to deal with the speed-quality tradeoff.