The evolution of the mass-metallicity relation in IllustrisTNG

TL;DR

This study uses the IllustrisTNG simulation to analyze the evolution of the gas-phase mass-metallicity relation in galaxies from redshift 0 to 10, revealing insights into metal retention, galaxy gas fractions, and the relation's scatter.

Contribution

It demonstrates that the IllustrisTNG model accurately reproduces the MZR evolution and provides new predictions for high-redshift galaxy metallicities and their dependence on gas fractions.

Findings

The MZR slope and normalization evolve consistently with observations from z=0 to 2.

Most gas-phase metals are outside the ISM, in the circumgalactic medium or beyond.

The MZR normalization decline is driven by higher gas fractions at high redshift.

Abstract

The coevolution of galaxies and their metal content serves as an important test for galaxy feedback models. We analyze the distribution and evolution of metals within the IllustrisTNG simulation suite with a focus on the gas-phase mass-metallicity relation (MZR). We find that the IllustrisTNG model broadly reproduces the slope and normalization evolution of the MZR across the redshift range $0<z<2$ and mass range $10^9 < M_*/\mathrm{M}_\odot < 10^{10.5}$. We make predictions for the high redshift ($2<z<10$) metal content of galaxies which is described by a gradual decline in the normalization of the metallicity with an average high redshift ($z>2$) evolution fit by $\mathrm{d\;log(Z)}/\mathrm{dz} \approx - 0.064$. Our simulations indicate that the metal retention efficiency of the interstellar medium (ISM) is low: a majority of gas-phase metals ($\sim$ 85 per cent at $z=0$) live outside of the ISM, either in an extended gas disk, the circumgalactic medium, or outside the halo. Nevertheless, the redshift evolution in the simulated MZR normalization is driven by the higher gas fractions of high redshift galaxies, not by changes to the metal retention efficiency. The scatter in the simulated MZR contains a clear correlation with the gas-mass or star formation rate of the system, in agreement with the observed fundamental metallicity relation. The scatter in the MZR is driven by a competition between periods of enrichment- and accretion-dominated metallicity evolution. We expect that while the normalization of the MZR declines with redshift, the strength of the correlation between metallicity and gas-mass at fixed stellar mass is not a strong function of redshift. Our results indicate that the "regulator" style models are best suited for simultaneously explaining the shape, redshift evolution, and existence of correlated scatter with gas fraction about the MZR.