NGC 6705 a young $\alpha$-enhanced Open Cluster from OCCASO data

TL;DR

This study reveals that the young open cluster NGC 6705/M11 exhibits significant alpha-element enhancement, challenging the idea that such chemical signatures are exclusive indicators of stellar age, and provides insights into its origin and chemical evolution.

Contribution

The paper presents the first detailed chemical abundance analysis of NGC 6705/M11 showing its alpha-enhancement despite its youth, questioning existing age-abundance paradigms.

Findings

NGC 6705/M11 has [$ mf alpha$/Fe] > 0.1 dex despite being only 300 Myr old.

The cluster's chemical profile aligns with young alpha-enhanced field stars.

Orbit analysis suggests a birth radius close to its current position, arguing against a Galactic bar origin.

Abstract

The stellar [$\alpha$/Fe] abundance is sometimes used as a proxy for stellar age, following standard chemical evolution models for the Galaxy, as seen by different observational results. In this work we show that the Open Cluster NGC6705/M11 has a significant $\alpha$-enhancement [$\alpha$/Fe]$>0.1$ dex, despite its young age ($\sim$300 Myr), challenging the current paradigm. We use high resolution (R$>65,000$) high signal-to-noise ($\sim$70) spectra of 8 Red Clump stars, acquired within the OCCASO survey. We determine very accurate chemical abundances of several $\alpha$ elements, using an equivalent width methodology (Si, Ca and Ti), and spectral synthesis fits (Mg and O). We obtain [Si/Fe]=$0.13\pm0.05$, [Mg/Fe]=$0.14\pm0.07$, [O/Fe]=$0.17\pm0.07$, [Ca/Fe]=$0.06\pm0.05$ and [Ti/Fe]=$0.03\pm0.03$. Our results place these cluster within the group of young [$\alpha$/Fe]-enhanced field stars recently found by several authors in the literature. The ages of our stars have an uncertainty of around 50 Myr, much more precise than for field stars. By integrating the cluster's orbit in several non-axisymmetric Galactic potentials, we establish the M11's most likely birth radius to lie between 6.8-7.5 kpc from the Galactic center, not far from its current position. With the robust Open Cluster age scale, our results prove that a moderate [$\alpha$/Fe]-enhancement is no guarantee for a star to be old, and that not all $\alpha$-enhanced stars can be explained with an evolved blue straggler scenario. Based on our orbit calculations, we further argue against a Galactic bar origin of M11.