Fundamental residual amplitude modulation in electro-optic modulators

TL;DR

This paper reveals that electro-optic modulators inherently produce a fundamental residual amplitude modulation (RAM) due to their operation, challenging standard assumptions and providing a classical model to quantify this effect, especially relevant for gravitational wave detectors.

Contribution

The study introduces a classical model demonstrating that EOMs generate a fundamental RAM, dependent on phase modulation depth and frequency ratio, contradicting standard textbook assumptions.

Findings

RAM depends on phase-modulation depth m

RAM depends on ratio Ω/ω₀

Model applied to gravitational wave detector EOMs

Abstract

The residual amplitude modulation ($\mathrm{RAM}$) is the undesired, non-zero amplitude modulation that usually occurs when a phase modulation based on the electro-optic effect is imprinted on a laser beam. In this work, we show that electro-optic modulators (EOMs) that are used to generate the sidebands on the laser beam also generate a $\mathrm{RAM}$ in the optical setup. This result contradicts standard textbooks, which assume the amplitude remains unchanged in the process and should be considered as a fundamental $\mathrm{RAM}$ ($\mathrm{RAM_{F}}$) for these devices. We present a classical model for the propagation of an infrared laser with frequency $\omega_{0}$ in a wedge-shaped crystal and an EOM with an RF modulating signal of frequency $\Omega$. Since ${\Omega}\ll \omega_{0}$, we solve Maxwell's equations in a time-varying media via a WKB approximation and we write the electromagnetic fields in terms of quasi-plane waves. From the emerging fields of the setup, we compute the associated $\mathrm{RAM_{F}}$ and show that it depends on the phase-modulation depth $m$ and the quotient $\left(\frac{\Omega}{\omega_{0}}\right)$. The $\mathrm{RAM_{F}}$ values obtained for the EOMs used in gravitational wave detectors are presented. Finally, the cancellation of $\mathrm{RAM_{F}}$ is analyzed.