Characteristics of Chiral Anomaly in View of Various Applications

TL;DR

This paper examines the fundamental aspects of chiral anomaly, clarifies misconceptions about Berry's phase and monopoles, and discusses its implications in condensed matter and lattice physics, highlighting that anomalies may be artifacts or vanish under certain conditions.

Contribution

It provides a detailed analysis of chiral anomaly origins, clarifies the role of Berry's phase and monopoles, and discusses lattice fermions, challenging common assumptions about anomalies in finite lattice systems.

Findings

Berry's phase assumes a monopole form at the adiabatic limit

Chiral anomaly for each species doubler vanishes at finite lattice spacing

Ginsparg-Wilson fermion defines a single Weyl fermion without doublers

Abstract

In view of the recent applications of chiral anomaly to various fields beyond particle physics, we discuss some basic aspects of chiral anomaly which may help deepen our understanding of chiral anomaly in particle physics also. It is first shown that Berry's phase (and its generalization) for the Weyl model $H =v_{F} \vec{\sigma}\cdot \vec{p}(t)$ assumes a monopole form at the exact adiabatic limit but deviates from it off the adiabatic limit and vanishes in the high frequency limit of the Fourier transform of $\vec{p}(t)$ for bounded $|\vec{p}(t)|$. An effective action, which is consistent with the non-adiabatic limit of Berry's phase, combined with the Bjorken-Johnson-Low prescription gives normal equal-time space-time commutators and no chiral anomaly. In contrast, an effective action with a monopole at the origin of the momentum space, which describes Berry's phase in the precise adiabatic limit but fails off the adiabatic limit, gives anomalous space-time commutators and a covariant anomaly to the gauge current. We regard this anomaly as an artifact of the postulated monopole and not a consequence of Berry's phase. As for the recent application of the chiral anomaly to the description of effective Weyl fermions in condensed matter and nuclear physics, which is closely related to the formulation of lattice chiral fermions, we point out that the chiral anomaly for each species doubler separately vanishes for a finite lattice spacing, contrary to the common assumption. Instead a general form of pair creation associated with the spectral flow for the Dirac sea with finite depth takes place. This view is supported by the Ginsparg-Wilson fermion, which defines a single Weyl fermion without doublers on the lattice and gives a well-defined index (anomaly) even for a finite lattice spacing.