Model-independent Constraints on Cosmic Curvature and Opacity

TL;DR

This study develops a model-independent method to simultaneously estimate the universe's spatial curvature and cosmic opacity using expansion rate data and supernova observations, revealing a preference for a flat, transparent universe and highlighting the importance of priors on the Hubble constant.

Contribution

It introduces a novel, model-independent approach combining Gaussian process reconstruction and global fitting to estimate curvature and opacity without assuming a specific cosmological model.

Findings

A flat, transparent universe is generally favored by the data.

The choice of H0 priors significantly influences the results.

There is a strong degeneracy between cosmic curvature and opacity.

Abstract

In this paper, we propose to estimate the spatial curvature of the universe and the cosmic opacity in a model-independent way with expansion rate measurements, $H(z)$, and type Ia supernova (SNe Ia). On the one hand, using a nonparametric smoothing method Gaussian process, we reconstruct a function $H(z)$ from opacity-free expansion rate measurements. Then, we integrate the $H(z)$ to obtain distance modulus $\mu_{\rm H}$, which is dependent on the cosmic curvature. On the other hand, distances of SNe Ia can be determined by their photometric observations and thus are opacity-dependent. In our analysis, by confronting distance moduli $\mu_{\rm H}$ with those obtained from SNe Ia, we achieve estimations for both the spatial curvature and the cosmic opacity without any assumptions for the cosmological model. Here, it should be noted that light curve fitting parameters, accounting for the distance estimation of SNe Ia, are determined in a global fit together with the cosmic opacity and spatial curvature to get rid of the dependence of these parameters on cosmology. In addition, we also investigate whether the inclusion of different priors for the present expansion rate ($H_0$: global estimation, $67.74\pm 0.46~\rm km~ s^{-1} ~Mpc^{-1}$, and local measurement, $73.24\pm 1.74~\rm km~ s^{-1} ~Mpc^{-1}$) exert influence on the reconstructed $H(z)$ and the following estimations of the spatial curvature and cosmic opacity. Results show that, in general, a spatially flat and transparent universe is preferred by the observations. Moreover, it is suggested that priors for $H_0$ matter a lot. Finally, we find that there is a strong degeneracy between the curvature and the opacity.