Geographically Coordinated Primary Frequency Control Technical Report

TL;DR

This paper develops distributed control laws for primary frequency control in power systems with geographically interdependent loads, ensuring stability, optimality, and cost savings, even with communication delays.

Contribution

It introduces novel distributed control laws that account for interdependent costs across locations, improving convergence and cost efficiency over existing methods.

Findings

Controlled frequencies are proven stable.

Final equilibrium balances load participation and frequency deviation.

Achieves faster convergence and cost savings compared to existing approaches.

Abstract

Primary Frequency Control (PFC) is a fast acting mechanism used to ensure high-quality power for the grid that is becoming an increasingly attractive option for load participation. Due to speed requirement and other considerations, it is often desirable to have distributed control laws. Current distributed PFC designs assume that the costs at each geographic location are independent. However, many networked systems, such as those for cloud computing, have interdependent costs across locations and therefore need geographic coordination. In this paper, distributed control laws are designed for interdependent, geo-distributed loads in PFC based on the optimality conditions of the global system. The controlled frequencies are provably stable, and the final equilibrium point is proven to strike an optimal balance between load participation and the frequency's deviation from its nominal set point. The case with a significant communication delay for control is also analyzed. We evaluate the proposed control laws with realistic numerical simulations. Under current technology, the proposed control laws achieve a convergence time that is smaller than droop control alone and is comparable to that of distributed control without interdependent costs. Results also highlight significant cost savings over existing approaches under a variety of settings.