A Touch of Evil: High-Assurance Cryptographic Hardware from Untrusted Components

TL;DR

This paper introduces Myst, a high-assurance cryptographic hardware architecture using COTS components, combining redundancy and threshold cryptography to ensure security despite malicious or faulty hardware components.

Contribution

The paper presents Myst, a practical architecture that achieves high security guarantees with COTS hardware by integrating redundancy and threshold cryptography to tolerate hardware Trojans and errors.

Findings

Over 100 COTS crypto-coprocessors used in prototype

Less than 1% overhead in cryptographic operations

Exponential increase in backdoor tolerance with more ICs

Abstract

The semiconductor industry is fully globalized and integrated circuits (ICs) are commonly defined, designed and fabricated in different premises across the world. This reduces production costs, but also exposes ICs to supply chain attacks, where insiders introduce malicious circuitry into the final products. Additionally, despite extensive post-fabrication testing, it is not uncommon for ICs with subtle fabrication errors to make it into production systems. While many systems may be able to tolerate a few byzantine components, this is not the case for cryptographic hardware, storing and computing on confidential data. For this reason, many error and backdoor detection techniques have been proposed over the years. So far all attempts have been either quickly circumvented, or come with unrealistically high manufacturing costs and complexity. This paper proposes Myst, a practical high-assurance architecture, that uses commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) hardware, and provides strong security guarantees, even in the presence of multiple malicious or faulty components. The key idea is to combine protective-redundancy with modern threshold cryptographic techniques to build a system tolerant to hardware trojans and errors. To evaluate our design, we build a Hardware Security Module that provides the highest level of assurance possible with COTS components. Specifically, we employ more than a hundred COTS secure crypto-coprocessors, verified to FIPS140-2 Level 4 tamper-resistance standards, and use them to realize high-confidentiality random number generation, key derivation, public key decryption and signing. Our experiments show a reasonable computational overhead (less than 1% for both Decryption and Signing) and an exponential increase in backdoor-tolerance as more ICs are added.