Approximate Stream Analytics in Apache Flink and Apache Spark Streaming

TL;DR

This paper introduces StreamApprox, a system for approximate stream analytics in Apache Flink and Spark Streaming, using an online stratified reservoir sampling algorithm to improve efficiency while maintaining accuracy.

Contribution

The paper presents a generic sampling algorithm for stream processing systems, enabling approximate analytics with error bounds in both batched and pipelined frameworks.

Findings

Achieves 1.15x-3x speedup over native systems.

Maintains accuracy comparable to exact processing.

Effective in real-world case studies.

Abstract

Approximate computing aims for efficient execution of workflows where an approximate output is sufficient instead of the exact output. The idea behind approximate computing is to compute over a representative sample instead of the entire input dataset. Thus, approximate computing - based on the chosen sample size - can make a systematic trade-off between the output accuracy and computation efficiency. Unfortunately, the state-of-the-art systems for approximate computing primarily target batch analytics, where the input data remains unchanged during the course of sampling. Thus, they are not well-suited for stream analytics. This motivated the design of StreamApprox - a stream analytics system for approximate computing. To realize this idea, we designed an online stratified reservoir sampling algorithm to produce approximate output with rigorous error bounds. Importantly, our proposed algorithm is generic and can be applied to two prominent types of stream processing systems: (1) batched stream processing such as Apache Spark Streaming, and (2) pipelined stream processing such as Apache Flink. We evaluated StreamApprox using a set of microbenchmarks and real-world case studies. Our results show that Spark- and Flink-based StreamApprox systems achieve a speedup of $1.15\times$-$3\times$ compared to the respective native Spark Streaming and Flink executions, with varying sampling fraction of $80\%$ to $10\%$. Furthermore, we have also implemented an improved baseline in addition to the native execution baseline - a Spark-based approximate computing system leveraging the existing sampling modules in Apache Spark. Compared to the improved baseline, our results show that StreamApprox achieves a speedup $1.1\times$-$2.4\times$ while maintaining the same accuracy level.