On the Iron Abundance Anomaly in K-dwarf and Hyades Stars

TL;DR

This study investigates the iron abundance discrepancy in K-dwarfs and Hyades stars, revealing that line-blending effects significantly impact measurements and that NLTE, age, and activity effects are minimal.

Contribution

It identifies the neglect of line-blending in Fe II lines as a key factor in the iron abundance anomaly, providing corrected measurements and analyzing potential physical causes.

Findings

Line-blending effects account for a large part of the Fe abundance discrepancy.

Removing specific Fe II lines reduces the abundance difference from 1.0 dex to about 0.3-0.6 dex.

NLTE, age, and activity effects are minor in explaining the anomaly.

Abstract

Using standard 1D-LTE model atmosphere analysis, we provide an in-depth investigation of iron abundance as derived from neutral and singly ionization iron lines (Fe {\scriptsize{I, II}}) in nearby star clusters. Specifically, we replicate the discrepancy regarding $\Delta$[Fe/H], wherein the difference of Fe {\scriptsize{II}} - Fe {\scriptsize{I}} increases for stars of the same cluster with decreasing $T_\mathrm{eff}$, reaching an astonishing 1.0 dex at $T_\mathrm{eff}$ $\thicksim$ 4000 K. Previous studies have investigated this anomaly in the Pleiades and Hyades clusters with no concrete solution. In this analysis, we probe two samples: 63 wide binary field stars where the primary star is of sun-like temperatures and the secondary is a K-dwarf, ranging from 4231 K $\leq$ $T_\mathrm{eff}$ $\leq$ 6453 K, and 33 Hyades stars of temperatures 4268 K $\leq$ $T_\mathrm{eff}$ $\leq$ 6072 K. Previous studies have found discrepancies on the order of 1.0 dex. However, we find that these studies have neglected line-blending effects of certain Fe {\scriptsize{II}} lines, namely $\lambda$ = \{4508.29 \AA, 4993.34 \AA, 5197.58 \AA, 5325.55 \AA, 5425.26 \AA, 6456.38 \AA\}. When these lines are removed from the line-list, we find $\Delta$[Fe/H] decreases to $\thicksim$ 0.6 dex in the field binaries and $\thicksim$ 0.3 dex in the Hyades. The reason for this remaining trend is investigated by probing NLTE effects, as well as age and activity considerations using Ca {\scriptsize{II}} H+K emission and Li absorption, but these results appear to be small to negligible.