Non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium abundance analyses of the extreme helium stars: V652 Her and HD 144941

TL;DR

This study performs a non-LTE abundance analysis of two extreme helium stars, V652 Her and HD 144941, revealing their atmospheric parameters and compositions, and supporting the white dwarf merger origin hypothesis.

Contribution

It provides the first consistent non-LTE atmospheric parameters and detailed elemental abundances for these stars, confirming merger models and highlighting the importance of non-LTE effects.

Findings

Non-LTE analysis yields consistent atmospheric parameters.

Neon abundance significantly affected by non-LTE effects.

V652 Her's composition matches slow helium white dwarf merger predictions.

Abstract

Optical high-resolution spectra of V652 Her and HD 144941, the two extreme helium stars with exceptionally low C/He ratios, have been subjected to a non-LTE abundance analysis using the tools TLUSTY and SYNSPEC. Defining atmospheric parameters were obtained from a grid of non-LTE atmospheres and a variety of spectroscopic indicators including He I and He II line profiles, ionization equilibrium of ion pairs such as C II/C III and N II/N III. The various indicators provide a consistent set of atmospheric parameters: $T_{\rm eff}$=25000$\pm$300K, $\log g$ = 3.10$\pm$0.12(cgs), and $\xi=13\pm2 {\rm km\,s^{-1}}$ are provided for V652 Her, and $T_{\rm eff}$=22000$\pm$600K, $\log g$ = 3.45$\pm$0.15 (cgs), and $\xi=10 {\rm km\,s^{-1}}$ are provided for HD 144941. In contrast to the non-LTE analyses, the LTE analyses - LTE atmospheres and a LTE line analysis - with the available indicators do not provide a consistent set of atmospheric parameters. The principal non-LTE effect on the elemental abundances is on the neon abundance. It is generally considered that these extreme helium stars with their very low C/He ratio result from the merger of two helium white dwarfs. Indeed, the derived composition of V652 Her is in excellent agreement with predictions by Zhang & Jeffery (2012) who model the slow merger of helium white dwarfs; a slow merger results in the merged star having the composition of the accreted white dwarf. In the case of HD 144941 which appears to have evolved from metal-poor stars a slow merger is incompatible with the observed composition but variations of the merger rate may account for the observed composition. More detailed theoretical studies of the merger of a pair of helium white dwarfs are to be encouraged.