Performance Measurements of Supercomputing and Cloud Storage Solutions

TL;DR

This paper compares the performance of supercomputing Lustre and cloud-based Amazon S3 storage solutions across various parallel I/O scenarios, providing insights for selecting appropriate storage based on workload and environment.

Contribution

It offers the first comprehensive performance measurements of Lustre and Amazon S3 under diverse parallel I/O workloads, guiding storage choice decisions.

Findings

Lustre achieves up to 0.35 terabits/sec on high-end hardware.

Amazon S3 reaches 10 gigabits/sec with parallel I/O.

Parallel I/O utilization enables full network bandwidth performance.

Abstract

Increasing amounts of data from varied sources, particularly in the fields of machine learning and graph analytics, are causing storage requirements to grow rapidly. A variety of technologies exist for storing and sharing these data, ranging from parallel file systems used by supercomputers to distributed block storage systems found in clouds. Relatively few comparative measurements exist to inform decisions about which storage systems are best suited for particular tasks. This work provides these measurements for two of the most popular storage technologies: Lustre and Amazon S3. Lustre is an open-source, high performance, parallel file system used by many of the largest supercomputers in the world. Amazon's Simple Storage Service, or S3, is part of the Amazon Web Services offering, and offers a scalable, distributed option to store and retrieve data from anywhere on the Internet. Parallel processing is essential for achieving high performance on modern storage systems. The performance tests used span the gamut of parallel I/O scenarios, ranging from single-client, single-node Amazon S3 and Lustre performance to a large-scale, multi-client test designed to demonstrate the capabilities of a modern storage appliance under heavy load. These results show that, when parallel I/O is used correctly (i.e., many simultaneous read or write processes), full network bandwidth performance is achievable and ranged from 10 gigabits/s over a 10 GigE S3 connection to 0.35 terabits/s using Lustre on a 1200 port 10 GigE switch. These results demonstrate that S3 is well-suited to sharing vast quantities of data over the Internet, while Lustre is well-suited to processing large quantities of data locally.