3D simulations of rising magnetic flux tubes in a compressible rotating interior: The effect of magnetic tension

TL;DR

This study develops a parameterization for the rise-time of magnetic flux tubes in solar-like stars, accounting for magnetic tension and non-axisymmetry, which can improve dynamo models and understanding of solar cycle variability.

Contribution

It introduces a control parameter based on magnetic tension and rotation effects, demonstrating its role in flux tube rise-time through numerical experiments, and provides a generalized relation for stellar applications.

Findings

Rise-time follows a power law with the control parameter.

Non-axisymmetry influences flux tube rise-time.

Compressibility does not significantly affect the rise of flux tubes.

Abstract

Context: Long-term variability in solar cycles represents a challenging constraint for theoretical models. Mean-field Babcock-Leighton dynamos that consider non-instantaneous rising flux tubes have been shown to exhibit long-term variability in their magnetic cycle. However a relation that parameterizes the rise-time of non-axisymmetric magnetic flux tubes in terms of stellar parameters is still missing. Aims: We aim to find a general parameterization of the rise-time of magnetic flux tubes for solar-like stars. Methods: By considering the influence of magnetic tension on the rise of non-axisymmetric flux tubes, we predict the existence of a control parameter referred as $\Gamma_{\alpha_1}^{\alpha_2}$. This parameter is a measure of the balance between rotational effects and magnetic effects (buoyancy and tension) acting on the magnetic flux tube. We carry out two series of numerical experiments (one for axisymmetric rise and one for non-axisymmetric rise) and demonstrate that $\Gamma_{\alpha_1}^{\alpha_2}$ indeed controls the rise-time of magnetic flux tubes. Results: We find that the rise-time follows a power law of $\Gamma_{\alpha_1}^{\alpha_2}$ with an exponent that depends on the azimuthal wavenumber of the magnetic flux loop. Conclusions: Compressibility does not impact the rise of magnetic flux tubes, while non-axisymmetry does. In the case of non-axisymmetric rise, the tension force modifies the force balance acting on the magnetic flux tube. We identified the three independent parameters required to predict the rise-time of magnetic flux tubes, that is, the stellar rotation rate, the magnetic flux density of the flux tube, and its azimuthal wavenumber. We combined these into one single relation that is valid for any solar-like star. We suggest using this generalized relation to constrain the rise-time of magnetic flux tubes in Babcock-Leighton dynamo models.