On spinodal points and Lee-Yang edge singularities

TL;DR

This paper investigates the analytic structure of the critical equation of state in $^4$ theory, connecting spinodal points and Lee-Yang singularities, and confirms the extended analyticity conjecture through various theoretical approaches.

Contribution

It provides a detailed analysis of the relation between spinodal points and Lee-Yang singularities, supporting the extended analyticity conjecture in non-mean-field dimensions.

Findings

Lee-Yang edge singularities are closest to the real magnetic field axis below $T_c$.

Spinodal singularities lie off the real axis for $d<4$, contrary to mean-field predictions.

The Ginzburg criterion is derived to delineate the non-mean-field region near Lee-Yang singularities.

Abstract

We address a number of outstanding questions associated with the analytic properties of the universal equation of state of the $\phi^4$ theory, which describes the critical behavior of the Ising model and ubiquitous critical points of the liquid-gas type. We focus on the relation between spinodal points that limit the domain of metastability for temperatures below the critical temperature, i.e., $T < T_{\rm c}$, and Lee-Yang edge singularities that restrict the domain of analyticity around the point of zero magnetic field $H$ for $T > T_{\rm c}$. The extended analyticity conjecture (due to Fonseca and Zamolodchikov) posits that, for $T < T_{\rm c}$, the Lee-Yang edge singularities are the closest singularities to the real $H$ axis. This has interesting implications, in particular, that the spinodal singularities must lie off the real $H$ axis for $d < 4$, in contrast to the commonly known result of the mean-field approximation. We find that the parametric representation of the Ising equation of state obtained in the $\varepsilon = 4-d$ expansion, as well as the equation of state of the ${\rm O}(N)$-symmetric $\phi^4$ theory at large $N$, are both nontrivially consistent with the conjecture. We analyze the reason for the difficulty of addressing this issue using the $\varepsilon$ expansion. It is related to the long-standing paradox associated with the fact that the vicinity of the Lee-Yang edge singularity is described by Fisher's $\phi^3$ theory, which remains nonperturbative even for $d\to 4$, where the equation of state of the $\phi^4$ theory is expected to approach the mean-field result. We resolve this paradox by deriving the Ginzburg criterion that determines the size of the region around the Lee-Yang edge singularity where mean-field theory no longer applies.