Specifying a positive threshold function via extremal points

TL;DR

This paper investigates the minimal sets of points needed to specify positive threshold Boolean functions, disproving a conjecture by showing non-nested functions can also have minimal specification sets of size n+1.

Contribution

It demonstrates that non-nested threshold functions can have a specification number of n+1, and characterizes when extremal points precisely determine the function.

Findings

Non-nested threshold functions with n+1 specification points exist.

The set of extremal points characterizes nested functions uniquely.

A structural understanding of extremal points is provided.

Abstract

An extremal point of a positive threshold Boolean function $f$ is either a maximal zero or a minimal one. It is known that if $f$ depends on all its variables, then the set of its extremal points completely specifies $f$ within the universe of threshold functions. However, in some cases, $f$ can be specified by a smaller set. The minimum number of points in such a set is the specification number of $f$. It was shown in [S.-T. Hu. Threshold Logic, 1965] that the specification number of a threshold function of $n$ variables is at least $n+1$. In [M. Anthony, G. Brightwell, and J. Shawe-Taylor. On specifying Boolean functions by labelled examples. Discrete Applied Mathematics, 1995] it was proved that this bound is attained for nested functions and conjectured that for all other threshold functions the specification number is strictly greater than $n+1$. In the present paper, we resolve this conjecture negatively by exhibiting threshold Boolean functions of $n$ variables, which are non-nested and for which the specification number is $n+1$. On the other hand, we show that the set of extremal points satisfies the statement of the conjecture, i.e., a positive threshold Boolean function depending on all its $n$ variables has $n+1$ extremal points if and only if it is nested. To prove this, we reveal an underlying structure of the set of extremal points.