A Generic Approach to Flow-Sensitive Polymorphic Effects (Extended Version)

TL;DR

This paper introduces effect quantales, an algebraic structure that models sequential effect systems with order sensitivity, providing a unified framework and new insights into their design and iteration mechanisms.

Contribution

It presents effect quantales as a novel algebraic foundation for sequential effect systems, enabling a general and principled approach to their design and iteration.

Findings

Effect quantales model a range of existing sequential effect systems.

Derived iteration aligns with prior manually designed operators.

Provides algebraic insights guiding the design of order-sensitive effect systems.

Abstract

Effect systems are lightweight extensions to type systems that can verify a wide range of important properties with modest developer burden. But our general understanding of effect systems is limited primarily to systems where the order of effects is irrelevant. Understanding such systems in terms of a lattice of effects grounds understanding of the essential issues, and provides guidance when designing new effect systems. By contrast, sequential effect systems --- where the order of effects is important --- lack a clear algebraic characterization. We derive an algebraic characterization from the shape of prior concrete sequential effect systems. We present an abstract polymorphic effect system with singleton effects parameterized by an effect quantale --- an algebraic structure with well-defined properties that can model a range of existing order-sensitive effect systems. We define effect quantales, derive useful properties, and show how they cleanly model a variety of known sequential effect systems. We show that effect quantales provide a free, general notion of iterating a sequential effect, and that for systems we consider the derived iteration agrees with the manually designed iteration operators in prior work. Identifying and applying the right algebraic structure led us to subtle insights into the design of order-sensitive effect systems, which provides guidance on non-obvious points of designing order-sensitive effect systems. Effect quantales have clear relationships to the recent category theoretic work on order-sensitive effect systems, but are explained without recourse to category theory. In addition, our derived iteration construct should generalize to these semantic structures, addressing limitations of that work.