The Impact of Road Configuration in V2V-based Cooperative Localization: Mathematical Analysis and Real-world Evaluation

TL;DR

This paper develops a mathematical framework to evaluate how road configurations and vehicle participation influence the accuracy of cooperative localization using GNSS data, supported by real-world traffic data analysis.

Contribution

It introduces a theoretical model for CMM error analysis and demonstrates how road directions and vehicle numbers affect localization accuracy.

Findings

CMM error decreases asymptotically with more vehicles

Uniformly distributed road directions minimize CMM error

Real-world data confirms theoretical predictions

Abstract

Cooperative map matching (CMM) uses the Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) position information of a group of vehicles to improve the standalone localization accuracy. It has been shown, in our previous work, that the GNSS error can be reduced from several meters to sub-meter level by matching the biased GNSS positioning to a digital map with road constraints. While further error reduction is expected by increasing the number of participating vehicles, fundamental questions on how the vehicle membership within CMM affects the performance of the CMM results need to be addressed to provide guidelines for design and optimization of the vehicle network. This work presents a theoretical study that establishes a framework for quantitative evaluation of the impact of the road constraints on the CMM accuracy. More specifically, a closed-form expression of the CMM error in terms of the road constraints and GNSS error is derived based on a simple CMM rule. The asymptotic decay of the CMM error as the number of vehicles increases is established and justified through numerical simulations. Moreover, it is proved that the CMM error can be minimized if the directions of the roads on which the connected vehicles travel obey a uniform distribution. Finally, the localization accuracy of CMM is evaluated based on the Safety Pilot Model Deployment and Pillar dataset of Ann Arbor traffic flow collected over three years period. The contributions of this work include establishing a theoretical foundation for CMM as well as providing insight and motivation for applications of CMM.