Water abundance in four of the brightest water sources in the southern sky
Bing-Ru Wang, Lei Qian, Di Li, Zhi-Chen Pan

TL;DR
This study measures water and nitrogen hydride abundances in four bright southern sky sources, revealing low water levels likely due to low temperatures, and provides detailed molecular abundance profiles.
Contribution
It offers new measurements of ortho-H2O and N2H+ abundances in specific molecular clumps, using multi-line observations and dust continuum data to estimate physical conditions.
Findings
Ortho-H2O abundances are low, around 10^{-10}.
N2H+ abundances decrease toward the clump centers.
Clump temperatures are derived from CS line ratios.
Abstract
We estimated the ortho-{\rm{HO}} abundances of G267.9--1.1, G268.4--0.9, G333.1--0.4 and G336.5--1.5, four of the brightest ortho-{\rm{HO}} sources in the southern sky observed by the Submillimeter Wave Astronomy Satellite (ortho-{\rm{HO}} 1 -- 1 line, 556.936~GHz). The typical molecular clumps in our sample have H column densities of to {\,}cm and ortho-{\rm{HO}} abundances of 10. Compared with previous studies, the ortho-{\rm{HO}} abundances are at a low level, which can be caused by the low temperatures of these clumps. To estimate the ortho-{\rm{HO}} abundances, we used the CS line (97.98095~GHz) and CS (244.93556~GHz) line observed by{ the} Swedish-ESO 15\,m Submillimeter Telescope (SEST) to calculate the temperatures of the clumps and the 350~m dust continuum observed…
| Transition | Frequency | Instrument | Beam Size | ||
| (GHz) | (kHz) | (km s-1) | |||
| Ortho-H2O 110 – 101 | 556.93599 | SWAS | 3.3′ 4.5′a | 0.55 | |
| CS (2–1) | 97.98095 | SEST | 42′′ | 43 | 0.13 |
| CS (5–4) | 244.93556 | SEST | 17′′ | 43b | 0.052b |
| N2H+ (1–0) | 93.17304 | SEST | 44′′ | 43 | 0.14 |
| Notes: a Melnick et al. 2000; b For G267.9–1.1, of the CS (5–4) line is 0.060 km s-1, and is 49 kHz. | |||||
| Clump | (2-1)/(5-4) | ex-clump (K) | CS-clump (cm-2) | av (cm-3) | av(cm-3) |
| CS-clump = 1013 cm-2 | CS-clump = 1014 cm-2 | ||||
| G267.9–1.1 | 1.0 | 22.4 | |||
| G268.4–0.9 | 2.5 | 11.5 | |||
| G333.1–0.4a | – | – | – | – | – |
| G336.5–1.5 | 1.7 | 14.8 | |||
| Notes: a We did not perform non-LTE analysis for clump G333.1-0.4 since there were only CS (5–4) data. | |||||
| Source | RA J2000 | Dec J2000 | Distance | Average ex | Mass | Average | SDf of | Average (H2) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (kpc) | (K) | () | (K) | (K) | (cm-2) | |||
| (1) | (2) | (3) | (4) | (5) | (6) | (7) | (8) | (9) |
| G267.9–1.1 | 08:59:12.00 | –47:29:04.0 | 1.5a | 26.5 | 31.1 | 30.7 | ||
| G268.4–0.9 | 09:01:54.30 | –47:43:59.0 | 1.3b | 11.5 | 11.5 | 1.4 | ||
| G333.1–0.4 | 16:21:02.10 | –50:35:15.0 | 3.6c | –e | 31.9 | – | ||
| G336.5–1.5 | 16:40:00.20 | –48:51:20.0 | 1.4d | 16.2 | 17.8 | 6.3 |
| (K) | G267.9–1.1 | G268.4–0.9 | G333.1–0.4 | G336.5–1.5 | |
| () | () | () | () | ||
| 5 | – | – | - | ||
| 10 | – | ||||
| 15 | – | ||||
| 20 | – | ||||
| 30 | – | ||||
| 40 | – | – | |||
| 50 | – | – | – | ||
| 60 | – | – | – | ||
| 80 | – | – | – |
| Clump | N2H+ Abundances |
|---|---|
| G267.9–1.1 | – |
| G268.4–0.9 | – |
| G333.1–0.4 | – |
| G336.5–1.5 | – |
Peer Reviews
No public reviews on file for this paper yet. If you reviewed it on a platform where reviews are public (OpenReview, ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML), you can paste yours below so the community can read it here.
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
\volnopage
2016 Vol. 16 No. 3, 39 (16pp) doi: 10.1088/1674–4527/16/3/039
11institutetext: National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100012, China; *[email protected]
*22institutetext: Key Laboratory of Radio Astronomy, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Nanjing 210008, China
\vs\vs\noReceived 2015 April 3; accepted 2015 September 11
Water abundance in four of the brightest water sources in the southern sky
Bing-Ru Wang 11
Lei Qian 11
Di Li 1122
Zhi-Chen Pan 11
Abstract
We estimated the ortho-H2O abundances of G267.9–1.1, G268.4–0.9, G333.1–0.4 and G336.5–1.5, four of the brightest ortho-H2O sources in the southern sky observed by the Submillimeter Wave Astronomy Satellite (ortho-H2O 110 – 101 line, 556.936 GHz). The typical molecular clumps in our sample have H2 column densities of to cm*-2* and ortho-H2O abundances of 10*-10*. Compared with previous studies, the ortho-H2O abundances are at a low level, which can be caused by the low temperatures of these clumps. To estimate the ortho-H2O abundances, we used the CS line (97.98095 GHz) and CS (244.93556 GHz) line observed by the Swedish-ESO 15 m Submillimeter Telescope (SEST) to calculate the temperatures of the clumps and the 350 m dust continuum observed by the Caltech Submillimeter Observatory (CSO) telescope to estimate the H2 column densities. The observations of N2H+ () for these clumps were also acquired by SEST and the corresponding abundances were estimated. The N2H+ abundance in each clump shows a common decreasing trend toward the center and a typical abundance range from 10*-11* to 10*-9*.
keywords:
ISM: abundances — (ISM:) HII regions — ISM: molecules — stars: formation
1 Introduction
Water was first detected in the interstellar medium (ISM) over 40 years ago (Cheung et al. 1969). It is an essential coolant in star-forming regions and plays an important role in the energy balance of prestellar objects (Doty & Neufeld 1997). Thus, the abundance of water is a crucial parameter, especially for massive star formation (Emprechtinger et al. 2010). Since the physical conditions of star-forming regions affect the water abundance (with respect to H2), water acts as an excellent diagnostic for energetic phenomena (Kristensen & van Dishoeck 2011). As an abundant oxygen-bearing molecule formed in molecular clouds, its abundance also gives constraints on the abundance of atomic oxygen, therefore it affects the abundances of other chemically related oxygen-bearing species.
Accessible water lines and feasible methods are necessary for estimating the abundance of water in star-forming-regions. Water lines originating from different levels probe gas under different conditions. Most rotational water lines, including the ground-state transition of ortho- and para-H2O, cannot be observed from the ground due to the existence of telluric water (Emprechtinger et al. 2010). Although there are indeed some transitions that have been detected from the ground, their upper states are over 200 K above the ground state (Snell et al. 2000a). The high energies over the ground state indicate high gas temperatures when collision with H2 is considered as the excitation mechanism. Thus, these transitions are unlikely to be from cold gases. To date, space observations, (e.g., the Submillimeter Wave Astronomy Satellite (SWAS) (Melnick et al. 2000); the Odin satellite; the Infrared Space Observatory (ISO); the Spitzer Space Telescope and the Herschel Space Observatory) have detected water lines, including the 556.936 GHz ortho-H2O 110 – 101 line. This ground-state transition was observed by SWAS first. With the upper state lying only 27 K above the ortho-H2O ground state, it provides access to estimate the water abundance in cold molecular gas, in which massive stars form in cold dense clumps and young stellar objects are deeply buried.
Water can form in several different routes, both in gas phase and on dust grains. Once they form, the H2O molecules can be desorbed from the ice mantle of dusts, remain frozen on the dust surface or freeze onto the dust grains from the gas phase. Water ice on the dust surface can desorb thermally when the dust temperature rises above about 100 K (Hollenbach et al. 2009). In another way, photodesorption occurs when the ice absorbs ultraviolet (UV) photons (van Dishoeck et al. 2013). When the temperature is as low as about 10 K and the density is high enough, freeze-out will dominate (Bergin & van Dishoeck 2012) and consequently lead to low H2O abundances. Thus, temperature and UV radiation are essential factors that affect water abundance.
To compare observations with predicted results, the abundances of para- or ortho-H2O are estimated based on the spectra obtained from telescopes. For the ortho-H2O line (110 – 101, 556.936 GHz), an effectively optically thin approximation (Snell et al. 2000a) was adopted, which makes it convenient to estimate the ortho-H2O abundance. In the Herschel key programme “water in star-forming regions with Hersehel” (WISH), the non-local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) radiative transfer code RADEX (van der Tak et al. 2007) was used to reduce the ortho-H2O line (110 – 101, 556.936 GHz) data to estimate the H2O abundance in a low-mass protostar (Kristensen et al. 2012). In this paper, we estimate the ortho-H2O abundances of four of the brightest ortho-H2O sources (G267.9–1.1, G268.4–0.9, G333.1–0.4 and G336.5–1.5) in the southern sky observed by SWAS. The paper is organized as follows: in Section 2, we briefly describe the observations of these clumps and the data reduction procedures. In Section 3, we present the calculations and estimates of clump temperatures, clump masses, H2 column densities and finally the estimate of ortho-H2O abundances based on observations. In Section 4 and Section 5, we present the discussion and conclusion respectively. The appendix contains some supplementary material.
2 Observation and Data Reduction
2.1 Source Selection
We checked the co-added spectra of the ortho-H2O 110 – 101 line of all the 386 sources in the five and a half years of the SWAS nominal mission from Lambda111http://lambda.gsfc.nasa.gov/product/swas/s_sw.cfm. We selected four of the sources with higher than 0.1 K (excluding the sources in the Galactic Center region) in the southern sky. These four sources are G267.9–1.1 ( = 0.10 K), G268.4–0.9 ( = 0.16 K), G333.1–0.4 ( = 0.20 K) and G336.5–1.5 ( = 0.45 K). Among these four sources, G336.5–1.5 has the highest .
These four sources are located in star forming regions RCW 38 (G267.9–1.1 and G268.4–0.9), RCW 106 (G333.1–0.4) and RCW 108 (G336.5–1.5), respectively. Although being bright at 8 m, they are all associated with the 22 GHz 616 –523 water masers (Kaufmann et al. 1976; Braz et al. 1989; Caswell et al. 1974 and Valdettaro et al. 2007), which are believed to be good indicators of the location of massive star formation (Juvela 1996). The properties of these four sources are summarized briefly as follows.
- (1)
G267.9–1.1. It is the third brightest source in the investigation of Galactic radio sources at 5000 MHz (Goss & Shaver 1970), with a brightness temperature of 124.0 K (Shaver & Goss 1970). The associated 22 GHz 616 –523 water maser (without OH main-line emission) was first reported by Kaufmann et al. (1976).
- (2)
G268.4–0.9. It was identified in an 11 cm survey of Vela (Manchester & Goss 1969), near the source G267.9–1.1 (denoted as G268.0–1.0 in the same survey) with a lower brightness temperature. However, it was not identified as an isolated radio source in the Galactic radio source survey (Goss & Shaver 1970). The associated 22 GHz water maser was identified by Braz et al. (1989).
- (3)
G333.1–0.4. It is one of the clumps in the giant molecular cloud (GMC) G333 (Lowe et al. 2014). It was first identified as an extensive H@slowromancapii@ region (Beard 1966), with a brightness temperature of 17.8 K (Shaver & Goss 1970). The associated 22 GHz water maser was identified by Caswell et al. (1974). The ortho-H2O 556.936 GHz line obtained by the SWAS exhibits a pronounced inverse P Cygni profile and related study (Li et al. 2004) suggests that it is a rare case of direct observational evidence for large scale infall in a star forming region.
- (4)
G336.5–1.5. It is identified as an isolated compact H@slowromancapii@ region in both the survey of H109 recombination line emission in Galactic H@slowromancapii@ regions of the southern sky (Wilson et al. 1970) and the investigation of Galactic radio sources at 5000 MHz (Goss & Shaver 1970). Its brightness temperature is 7.2 K (Shaver & Goss 1970). G336.5–1.5 is associated with bright-rimmed cloud (BRC) 79, one of the 89 clouds in a catalog of BRCs with IRAS point sources (Sugitani & Ogura 1994). It has the largest H2 column density among the 43 southern hemisphere BRCs (BRC 77 and BRC 78 excluded) and the H@slowromancapii@ region RCW 62, according to 13CO observations (Yamaguchi et al. 1999). Its ortho-H2O 556.936 GHz line obtained by SWAS exhibits the highest antenna temperature among all observed sources (other than solar system objects and the Galactic Center), which makes it an interesting object to study.
Compared with the other three sources, G336.5–1.5 has a higher Galactic latitude. Its associated 22 GHz water maser was detected in a survey of 45 southern BRCs (Sugitani & Ogura 1994) for H2O maser emission (Valdettaro et al. 2007), with a total integrated H2O flux density of merely 5.4 Jy km s*-1*. All these features mentioned above imply that these four sources are likely to be massive star forming active clumps. We use “clumps” to refer to these four sources in this paper.
2.2 Observation and Data Reduction
The observations were carried out with three telescopes. The ortho-H2O 110 – 101 line (556.936 GHz) was observed with SWAS. The CS line (97.98095 GHz), CS line (244.93556 GHz) and N2H+ line (93.17340 GHz) data were from the Swedish-ESO 15 m Submillimeter Telescope (SEST222http://www.eso.org/public/images/esopia00049teles/). The 350 m dust continuum data were obtained with the Submillimeter High Angular Resolution Camera II (SHARC II; see Dowell et al. 2003) of the Caltech Submillimeter Observatory (CSO) telescope. The observational parameters of molecular lines are listed in Table 1.
2.2.1 SWAS observation
The observations of the ortho-H2O 110 – 101 line (556.936 GHz) were performed with SWAS from 1999 January 20 to 2001 May 3 (G267.9–1.1), 1998 December 20 to 2003 June 5 (G268.4–0.9), 1999 September 15 to 2002 February 25 (G333.1–0.4) and 2001 September 22 to 2004 July 21 (G336.5–1.5). The data were obtained from the SWAS spectrum service in the NASA/IPAC infrared science archive333http://irsa.ipac.caltech.edu/applications/SWAS/SWAS/list.html.
The ortho-H2O 557 GHz 110 – 101 line data acquired by SWAS were converted into FITS format with a uniform 190 190 arcsec2 pixel size after the spectra in every single beam (which are also in the same sampling cell) were averaged and then the baselines were substracted. The Gildas software package444http://www.iram.fr/IRAMFR/GILDAS/ was used for averaging and baseline subtraction. The baselines of spectra were acceptable and a 1st or 2nd order polynomial was used for baseline fitting. The typical root mean squares (RMSs) of the ortho-H2O 557 GHz 110 – 101 spectra are 0.017 K for G267.9–1.1, 0.013 K for G268.4–0.9, 0.014 K for G333.1–0.4, and 0.03 K for G336.5–1.5. The different RMSs are mainly due to different integration times. When we calculated the integrated intensities of the ortho-H2O 557 GHz 110 – 101 line, the antenna temperatures were corrected with a main beam efficiency of 0.9.
For G268.4–0.9 and G333.1–0.4, the antenna temperatures below zero are due to the high noises and the subtraction of the baseline. The double-peaked spectra of ortho-H2O 110 - 101 lines of G268.4–0.9 indicated strong self-absorption (Ashby et al. 2000). We performed a Gaussian fitting for both non-absorbed emission peaks and the absorption peaks and obtained the integrated intensity of the emission of the averaged and baseline subtracted spectrum. The spectrum of G333.1–0.4 shows a pronounced inverse P Cygni profile. We took into account both the water components corresponding to emission and absorption features.
2.2.2 SEST observation
The observations of the CS line (97.98095 GHz), CS line (244.93556 GHz) and N2H+ line (93.17632 GHz) were carried out with SEST. These four clumps were mapped with CS (except for G333.1–0.4), CS and N2H+ in 2002 Mar 24–28. The main-beam efficiencies were 0.73 (CS ), 0.56 (CS ) (Lapinov et al. 1998) and 0.74 (N2H+ ) (Mardones et al. 1997), respectively.
In the mappings, the spacing of the square scanning grids is , but in the CS (5–4) mappings for G268.4–0.9, G333.1–0.4 and G336.5–1.5, additional sampling made the square scanning grids quincunxes. In each map, every pixel was observed with the position switch mode separately. The reference positions are selected approximately 1800*′′* away from the centers of the maps (the coordinates in Columns (2) and (3) of Table 3).
The Gildas software package was also used. For several spectra, the baselines seem to follow a sine function but with changing periods and amplitudes. In addition, for several spectra the line widths of the real emission lines are similar to the periods of their sine baselines, so we left them with their sinusoidal baselines. We check all the spectra one by one for baseline fitting. These spectra are near the edge of the mapping area and our calculation results are affected little.
After the baseline subtraction, the obtained spectra with RMSs less than 1 K (for CS in G333.1–0.4 and G336.5–1.5, the sigma limits are 0.5 K and 0.84 K, respectively) were selected and written in FITS format with a uniform arcsec2 pixel size.
The RMSs of the CS (2–1) spectra in the center of the images are 0.16 K for G267.9–1.1 (RA = 08:59:12.0, Dec = 47:29:04), 0.16 K for G268.4–0.9 (RA = 09:01:54.3, Dec = 47:43:59) and 0.16 K for G336.5–1.5 (RA = 16:39:58.9, Dec = 48:51:00). The RMSs of the CS (5–4) spectra in the center of the images are 0.42 K for G267.9–1.1 (RA = 08:59:12.0, Dec = 47:29:04), 0.16 K for G268.4–0.9 (RA = 09:01:54.3, Dec = 47:43:59), 0.13 K for G333.1–0.4 (RA = 16:21:02.1, Dec = 50:35:15), and 0.09 K for G336.5–1.5 (RA = 16:39:58.9, Dec = 48:51:00).
We did not have CS (2–1) data for G333.1–0.4. The RMSs of the N2H+ (1–0) spectra in the center of the images are 0.20 K for G267.9–1.1 (RA = 08:59:12.0, Dec = 47:29:04), 0.18 K for G268.4–0.9 (RA = 09:01:54.3, Dec = 47:43:59), 0.19 K for G333.1–0.4 (RA = 16:21:00.8, Dec = 50:34:55), and 0.17 K for G336.5–1.5 (RA = 16:39:58.9, Dec = 48:51:00).
2.2.3 CSO observation
The 350 m dust continuum observations were performed with SHARC II on CSO during 2014 April 4 and 5. The data were taken when these four regions were close to their maximum elevation (approximately 20 degrees at the CSO site) and the was lower than 0.06. The box scan mode was used for the SHARC II observation. The beam size of SHARC II is 8*′′* and the grid spacing for the sampling is 1.5 1.5 arcsec2. For each scan, the total integration time is 14.71 minutes and the corresponding RMS is 212 mJy beam*-1*. Pointing and focusing calibration was done every 2 hours during the observation. The data reduction tool CRUSH555http://www.submm.caltech.edu/ sharc/crush/ was used for further data reduction. The flux calibration was done by observing Mars. The RMS for the final data are 0.49 Jy beam*-1* for G267.9–1.1, 0.61 Jy beam*-1* for G268.4–0.9, 0.79 Jy beam*-1* for G333.1–0.4 and 0.53 Jy beam*-1* for G336.5–1.5. The weather is the main reason for the variation of the noises in different maps.
3 Results and Analysis
3.1 Spectra Map and Dust Map
Figures 1, 2, 3 and 4 are line profile maps of G267.9–1.1, G268.4–0.9, G333.1–0.4 and G333.6–1.5. In these line profile maps, all offsets are relative to the corresponding coordinates (see Table 3) and the units are arcsec. Empty boxes are the positions without sampling.
There is a “hole” with little CS (2–1 and 5–4) emission in the center of the emission region of G267.9–1.1. Moreover, the centroid velocities of the CS spectra in the east of the hole are different from those of the CS spectra in the west of the hole. In the south of the hole, the CS spectra all have two obvious peaks and in the north of the hole, the spectra all have two peaks as well. We overlapped the CS (2–1) integrated intensity map on the 350 m dust continuum in Figure 6. We can see that the intensity peaks are associated with the 350 m emission and in the “hole” the dust emission is much weaker than the surrounding areas.
The RMSs of CS (5–4) spectra of G333.1–0.4 vary a lot, which is caused by different integration times. The integration time (on source time) changes from less than 0.8 minutes to more than 3 minutes. In G336.5–1.5’s CS (5–4) spectra, there are similar situations.
The 350 m dust continuums of these four clumps are shown in Figure 6. In the following sections, we estimated the temperatures, masses, H2 column densities and ortho-water abundances of these four clumps. The areas for mass and ortho-water abundance estimates are shown in white boxes with solid lines and dashed lines, in the corresponding figures, respectively.
3.2 CS Excitation Temperatures
3.2.1 The estimate of CS excitation temperatures
For G267.9–1.1, G268.4–0.9 and G336.5–1.5 (we did not have CS (2–1) line data for G333.1–0.4) the excitation temperatures of the CS molecule were estimated based on the CS (2–1) line and CS (5–4) line. The estimated CS excitation temperatures were subsequently adopted in the estimates of clump masses (and then the H2 column densities), ortho-water abundances and N2H+ abundances.
The estimate is based on the following assumptions, i.e., (1) The CS molecules are in LTE. (2) The cosmic microwave background radiation (CMB) can be ignored. (3) CS (2–1) and CS (5–4) lines are optically thin. Since G267.9–1.1, G268.40.9 and G336.5–1.5 all fill the main beam, the filling factors in the estimate equal 1. According to the population diagram method (in LTE) (Goldsmith & Langer 1999), for the upper levels and there are
[TABLE]
and
[TABLE]
respectively. N$${}_{\rm{J=2}}^{\rm{thin}} and N$${}_{\rm{J=5}}^{\rm{thin}} are the column densities at and in the optically thin situation respectively. J=2 and J=5 are the statistical weights of level and level respectively, and 5-4 and 2-1 are the corresponding optical depths. tot is the total column density of the CS molecule and is the partition function. ex is the excitation temperature of these two transitions. Since we assumed that the CS (2–1) line and CS (5–4) line are optically thin, we considered
[TABLE]
and
[TABLE]
From Equations (1), (2), (3) and (4), we obtained
[TABLE]
while
[TABLE]
is the rotational quantum number and e is the rotational constant of the CS molecule at vibrational energy level = 0 in Hz ( Hz, Kewley et al. 1963). The statistical weights of the and level, J=2 and J=5, equal 5 and 11 respectively. Thus, we can write Equation (5) as
[TABLE]
Now we focus on the CS column densities of the upper levels ( and ). Based on Rohlfs & Wilson (1996), when the molecular line is optically thin, the column densities of the upper level ( or ) are
[TABLE]
where is the frequency of the CS (2–1) or CS (5–4) line, ex is the excitation temperature, ul is the corresponding Einstein -coefficient and ν is the optical depth. In an isothermal medium, the relationship between the brightness temperature , the excitation temperature ex and the cosmic background temperature background can be described as
[TABLE]
When the CS lines are optically thin,
[TABLE]
and if the background radiation can be ignored, then
[TABLE]
Substituting Equation (11) into Equation (8), we obtained
[TABLE]
Since the four clumps in our study are all extended sources, the antenna temperature a , and the column densities of upper levels in the optically thin case are
[TABLE]
In Equation (13), N$${}_{\rm{u}}^{\rm{thin}} is dependent on ex.
If we adopt the Rayleigh-Jeans approximation
[TABLE]
in Equation (13), then this equation will be reduced to
[TABLE]
This expression is the same as that from Goldsmith & Langer (1999), and it does not depend on the excitation temperature ex.
However, we notice that if we estimate the column densities of upper levels through Equation (15), then significant deviation will arise due to the high frequency of the CS (5–4) line. The deviation in upper level column densities will lead to significant deviation of the subsequently derived ex.
The excitation-temperature-dependent N$${}_{\rm{u}}^{\rm{thin}} was derived by correcting the N$${}_{\rm{u}}^{\rm{thin}\ast} with line frequency and excitation temperature ex
[TABLE]
For each sampling position, we need N$${}_{\rm{u}}^{\rm{thin}} at the and level to calculate the excitation temperature of CS, while the excitation temperature of the CS molecule is required when we derived N$${}_{\rm{u}}^{\rm{thin}} (Eq. (16)). As a start, we calculated N$${}_{\rm{u}}^{\rm{thin}\ast} for the and level (Eq. (15)) and then we derived an excitation temperature (Eq. (7)) from N$${}_{\rm{u}}^{\rm{thin}\ast} ( and level). In the next step, we obtained the first N$${}_{\rm{u}}^{\rm{thin}} through Equation (16), with which we subsequently calculated an excitation temperature again (Eq. (7)). Since N$${}_{\rm{u}}^{\rm{thin}} is dependent on ex, and ex is derived from N$${}_{\rm{u}}^{\rm{thin}}s ( = 2 and = 5 level), we performed iterative calculations to correct ex gradually, i.e., we ran the iteration cycles of “ – .” We kept comparing the latest ex calculated from the latest N$${}_{\rm{u}}^{\rm{thin}}s at the = 2 and = 5 level with the previously calculated ex. The iterations would not end until the absolute value of the difference between these two ex values was less than 0.05 K.
The calculation of CS excitation temperatures was only applied to the positions where both the CS (2–1) and CS (5–4) line intensities were higher than 3. At these positions, gas along the line of sight would be considered CS (5–4)-traced dense gas and the areas corresponding to all these positions are treated as “CS (5–4)-traced areas,” in which the CS molecules can be well-excited through collisions (at least for the CS = 1 2 excitation, since the critical density of the CS (5–4) line is far greater than that of the CS (2–1) line) and the calculated CS excitation temperatures approximately equal the kinetic temperatures of the gas; the kinetic temperature of the gas is an essential parameter in subsequent estimates. Considering the sampling spacing (comparing it with the beam size), no interpolation was applied to positions where the quality of signal is poor (low signal-to-noise ratio) and the corresponding CS column densities at = 2 and = 5 as well as the s were denoted as zero at these positions. The average CS excitation temperatures of these four clumps (corresponding to the areas within the white boxes (solid lines) in Fig. 6) are listed in Column (5) of Table 3. In those areas all calculated CS excitation temperatures are non-zero. We subsequently estimated the masses of the clumps within these white boxes (solid lines) in Section 3.3.
We also derived a “characteristic” CS excitation temperature, ex-clump, for the CS (5–4)-traced area in each clump (G267.9–1.1, G268.4–0.9 and G336.5–1.5). For each clump, we averaged the integrated intensity of the CS (2–1) line (and CS (5–4) line, as well) at every sample position in the CS (5–4)-traced area (the white boxes (solid lines) in Fig. 6), then with these average integrated intensities we derived the “characteristic” excitation temperatures ex-clump through exactly the same assumptions and processes as we previously described.
Figure 7 shows the population diagrams calculated for the ex-clumps of G267.9–1.1, G268.4–0.9 and G336.5–1.5. The population diagrams were deduced from corresponding N$${}_{\rm{u}}^{\rm{thin}\ast}s (at = 2 and = 5, in dashed lines) and the last N$${}_{\rm{u}}^{\rm{thin}}s (at = 2 and = 5, in solid lines) we retrieved in the iteration. We can see that the correction of the upper level column densities ( = 2 and = 5) for the Rayleigh-Jeans approximation does make a difference in the slopes of these plots. We derived the final values for the ex-clumps, i.e., those deduced from the slopes of the plots in solid lines in Figure 7, were listed in Table 2, together with CS-clump, the average CS column density in the CS (5–4)-traced area of each clump. The average CS column density in the CS (5–4)-traced area was deduced from the final results of the iteration for ex-clump.
3.2.2 The non-LTE analysis for CS (2–1) and CS (5–4) lines
Since it is possible for the CS lines to be optically thick (especially for the CS (2–1) line) in the actual situation, we also performed non-LTE analysis for the CS (2–1) and CS (5–4) lines with RADEX (van der Tak et al. 2007) in the CS (5–4)-traced areas (the white boxes with solid lines in Fig. 6). To perform this analysis, for each clump we added up the integrated intensities of the CS (2–1) line and CS (5–4) line at every sample position in the CS (5–4)-traced area (the white boxes (solid lines) in Fig. 6) respectively and found the corresponding average values. Based on the average CS (2–1) and CS (5–4) integrated intensities we derived the line intensity ratio (2-1)/(5-4) (CS (2–1)/CS (5–4)) in the CS (5–4)-traced area for each clump. We then performed the non-LTE analysis with RADEX in a kinetic temperature range from 10 K to 200 K and an H2 density range from 103 to 108 cm*-3*. According to the CS-clump we had estimated for each clump (see Section 3.2.1), we performed the analysis with CS column densities of 1013 cm*-2* and 1014 cm*-2* and got the line intensity ratio maps on the kinetic temperature (kin)-density plane. To estimate the probable H2 density within the CS (5–4)-traced area for each clump, we need the corresponding kinetic temperature in addition to the (2-1)/(5-4). When we took their ex-clumps as the corresponding kinetic temperatures in the CS (5–4)-traced areas (and this is in accordance with the LTE assumption which we would adopt in the following estimates), the clumps are marked on the maps as Figures 8 and 9 show. The corresponding average H2 densities of the clumps within the CS (5–4)-traced areas, avs, are listed in Table 2 together with other parameters. The non-LTE analysis suggests that all these clumps have quite high avs in the CS (5–4)-traced areas. The non-LTE analysis results offer references for assuming densities in the subsequent estimates. We did not perform non-LTE analysis for G333.1–0.4 since we only obtained CS (5–4) data.
3.3 Clump Masses and H2 Column Densities
To estimate the H2 column densities of these four clumps, we adopted the assumptions made in Li et al. (2007), namely,
- (i)
The medium along a certain line of sight has a single temperature (Goldsmith et al. 1997);
- (ii)
The absorption coefficient at 350 m, (350), is 10*-4*;
- (iii)
The characteristic grain radius is 0.1 m;
- (iv)
The grain density is 3 g cm*-3*;
- (v)
The gas to dust ratio (GDR) is 100.
The clump mass can be expressed as
[TABLE]
where is the flux density of the cloud at 350 m at distance , in Jy, d is the dust temperature, f(Td) is the Planck factor and
[TABLE]
In this formula (Li et al. 2007), the dust temperature is an essential parameter. Although high density gases are present in these clumps, there can be a significant difference between the dust and gas temperatures at the same position (Goldsmith et al. 1997). However, when (H2) = 106 cm*-3*, the dust temperature approximately equals the gas temperature (Li et al. 2007). Thus we can assume that along a certain line of sight the dust temperature equals the local gas temperature in this volume density condition. Since the CS (5–4) transition has a critical density of about 106 cm*-3*, we assume that within the boundaries of CS (5–4)-traced areas (H2) = 106 cm*-3*. According to our non-LTE analysis with RADEX (in Section 3.2.2), this assumption is reasonable and we therefore adopt the approximation of dust temperature above in the following estimate.
Here we assume the gas temperature equals the kinetic temperature. Based on the relation between the CS excitation temperatures and the kinetic temperatures mentioned before, we actually adopted the calculated CS excitation temperatures as the local gas temperatures and the dust temperatures along the same lines of sight in the CS (5–4)-traced areas.
In the 350 m emission data, the grid spacing for the sampling is arcsec2. By summing up the calculated mass of every cell in the sampling grid, we calculated the total mass of each clump666“The total mass” is the sum of the calculated mass of every single cell in each white box with solid lines in Figure 6. The boundaries of each box were determined based on the CS (5–4)-traced area, the area with available calculated CS excitation temperatures and the profile of the 350 m image (for G267.9–1.1).. Subsequently we estimated the H2 column densities for each of the clumps cell by cell as
[TABLE]
where Mclump(cell) is the calculated mass of every single cell, is the mass fraction of H in gas with a 4He to H ratio of 0.08459 (Balser 2006). is the distance from the clump, and is the sampling grid spacing, which is 1.5*′′. Since the CS (5–4) line has a high critical density of about 106 cm-3* and referencing our non-LTE analysis with RADEX (in Section 3.2.2) we assume that the element H is all in the form of H2 in the dense gases within the CS (5–4)-traced areas when we calculated the molecular hydrogen column densities. The calculated clump masses (of the CS (5–4)-traced areas, within the white boxes (solid lines) in Fig. 6) are listed in Column (6) of Table 3. The average H2 column densities in the areas used to estimate the ortho-H2O abundance (white boxes (dashed lines) in Fig. 6) are listed in Column (9) of Table 3. The H2 column densities in these four clumps are on the order of magnitude 1022 cm*-2* or 1023 cm*-2*.
3.4 Ortho-H2O Abundance
3.4.1 Method
The observation of the 557 GHz ortho-H2O 110 – 101 line was performed with SWAS with a pixel size of about arcsec2 and a main beam efficiency of about 0.90 (Melnick 1995). This ground-state transition has a large spontaneous emission rate, . As the stimulated absorption coefficient is proportional to the spontaneous emission rate, it leads to large opacities and makes excitation by photon trapping important (Wannier et al. 1991). Since the collisional de-excitation rate coefficient is far less than , this line has a high critical density and the excitation is subthermal (in other words, the de-excitation of upper level molecules is dominated by emission photons rather than collisional de-excitation). Thus, although the line is expected to be optically thick at the line center even for a relatively low water abundance, every collisionally excited upper level molecule can always produce a photon which finally escapes the cloud (Snell et al. 2000a). Thus, the optically thick gas can be effectively thin (Snell et al. 2000a). Therefore, the integrated antenna temperature is proportional to the column density of ortho-H2O under known temperature and H2 volume density, according to Snell et al. (2000a),
[TABLE]
b is the integrated intensity, in K km s*-1*. is the collisional de-excitation rate coefficient from level 110 to level 101.
3.4.2 Kinetic temperature and other details
Equation (20) can be written as
[TABLE]
with
[TABLE]
where is a constant at a given temperature.
We adopted an H2 volume density of 106 cm*-3* in the estimates since the areas where we estimated the ortho-H2O abundances (the white boxes with dashed lines in Fig. 6) are in the CS (5–4)-traced areas. The average H2 column densities in the white boxes with dashed lines are listed in Column (9) of Table 3.
The value of coefficient depends on the kinetic temperature and the corresponding . Assuming that CS lines and the ortho-H2O 110 – 101 line originate from the same gas, we take the calculated CS excitation temperatures as the kinetic temperature at corresponding areas and adopt them in the estimate of ortho-water abundance. Since the pixel size of ortho-H2O data is much larger than that of the CS lines (the sampling spacing), there is an average effect for the kinetic temperature. We calculated the average and the corresponding standard deviation (Table 3, Column (7) and (8)) to restrict the temperature range for the estimate. The collisional de-excitation rate coefficients were calculated according to the effective collisional excitation rate of ortho-H2O from level 110 to level 101 (hereafter the effective excitation rate) by para- or ortho-H2 and the ortho to para ratio of H2. The effective excitation rates were adopted from Dubernet et al. (2009) and Daniel et al. (2011)777i.e., the “effective rate coefficient” in these two papers from 5 K to 80 K. Assuming that H2 molecules are in LTE, the ortho to para ratios of H2 were derived according to the H2 rotational energy levels from Dabrowski (1984) and the fractional population in the H2 rotational levels (Phillips et al. 1996).
3.4.3 Ortho-H2O abundances
The values of (see Eq. (21)) and the estimated ortho-H2O abundances at the kinetic temperatures for every clump are listed in Table 4.
The ortho-H2O abundances in the most probable temperature ranges of these four clumps (i.e., G267.9-1.1, 30–40 K; G268.4–0.9, 10–15 K; G333.1–0.4, 30–40 K; G336.5–1.5, 15–20 K. The corresponding ortho-H2O abundances were called “the typical ortho-H2O abundances” in Section 4.1) are presented in Figure 10 together with some other ortho-H2O water abundances of giant molecular cloud (GMC) cores (Snell et al. 2000b) and molecular outflows (Franklin et al. 2008), which are based on the same ortho-H2O transition observed by SWAS. The ortho-H2O abundances of these four clumps are at a low level compared with other results.
3.5 N2H+ Abundances
Since the critical density of the N2H+ (1–0) line is far lower than that of the CS (5–4) line, we can assume that CS lines ((5–4) and (2–1)) and the N2H+ (1–0) line are all thermally populated in the CS (5–4)-traced areas, thus their excitation temperatures are all approximately equal to the kinetic temperatures. In this situation, we can adopt the excitation temperatures of CS as the excitation temperatures of N2H+ at the same positions. Then with the same assumptions and approximations we used in calculation of the column density of upper level CS molecules, we calculate the corrected N2H+ column density at . The N2H+ column density is estimated as
[TABLE]
according to Rohlfs & Wilson (1996). J=1 is the N2H+ column density without the Rayleigh-Jeans approximation at . is the rotational constant of the N2H+ molecule at vibrational energy level 888http://www.cv.nrao.edu/php/splat/species_metadata_displayer.php? species_id=148. is the rotational quantum number of the upper level and . is the Boltzmann constant and is the Planck constant. We adopt the excitation temperatures of CS as the temperature . is the rotational partition function of N2H+. Since N2H+ is a linear molecule (Mangum & Shirley 2015), when the contribution of the vibrational excited states is not taken into account,
[TABLE]
is the rigid rotor rotational constant of the N2H+ molecule at the ground vibrational state and MHz (Mangum & Shirley 2015). is the rotational quantum number and . and are as the same as in Equation (23).
According to Mangum & Shirley (2015), if we use one or several hyperfine transition(s) that can be observed to derive the column density of N2H+, we must take the relative line strengths of the hyperfine transition(s) into consideration. However, in our observation the spectra cover all the seven hyperfine transitions which can be observed in the transition. Thus, we just calculate the rotational partition functions at corresponding temperatures and then estimate the N2H+ column densities. We average the estimated H2 column densities at every N2H+ pixel and then estimate the N2H+ abundances. The results are shown in Table 5 and Figure 11 and all offsets are relative to the corresponding coordinates (J2000) in Table 3 and the unit is arcsec.
4 Discussion
4.1 Ortho-H2O Abundances
The typical ortho-H2O abundances of these four clumps are in the range – for G267.9–1.1, – for G268.4–0.9, – for G333.1–0.4 and around for G336.5–1.5.
The typical ortho-H2O abundances are at a low level compared with those of cold ( K) GMC cores estimated with the same principle by Snell et al. (2000b). The upper limits of the ortho-H2O abundances of these four clumps are on the order of , lower than the abundances of most of the GMC cores in Snell et al. (2000b). In our estimate, the effective excitation rates we adopted for para-H2 () are larger than those from Phillips et al. (1996) by a factor of 1–3 at temperatures from 20 K to 80 K. This fact should be noticed when comparing our results with the results in Snell et al. (2000b) or Franklin et al. (2008) (see Fig. 10).
The low abundances may be caused by the low temperatures of these clumps if we consider the water vapor originating from the interior of the clumps. Even at temperatures as low as 10 K, water can form in the ISM (van Dishoeck et al. 2013). However, at such low temperatures and high densities, the freeze-out procedure dominates (Bergin & van Dishoeck 2012) and until the temperature is above about 100 K (Hollenbach et al. 2009), water molecules can be desorbed through thermal sublimation. Also, in the interior of the dense clump, the desorption of frozen water molecules is unlikely to be caused by photodesorption. Although there is an average effect for the temperature in the large SWAS beam (and in the ortho-H2O pixels, also), we can find that the areas along the line of sight from where the ortho-H2O emissions originate are quite cold, or in other words, are not warm enough to produce much water vapor. Consequently the ortho-H2O abundances are low.
On the other hand, since these clumps are all located in star forming regions, the ortho-H2O emission therefore can originate primarily at the intermediate depth of these clumps where neither the photodissociation nor the freezing out of the H2O molecules, but the photodesorption process dominates according to a model for the temperature and chemical structure in molecular clouds (Hollenbach et al. 2009). Thus, since we took the H2 column densities along the line of sight to estimate the abundances, it consequently results in apparent low ortho-H2O abundance for the whole clump while in the photodesorbed layer the water vapor is actually more abundant.
In addition, there are also considerations of possible factors which can cause the apparent low ortho-H2O abundances of those clumps but have been masked due to the averaging effect of the large SWAS beam. For example, small structures in the clump such as a hot outflow may contribute the majority of the observed gaseous water. The water abundance may vary greatly within the same clump. A similar phenomenon has been confirmed in the outflow powered by L1157-mm (a low-mass Class 0 protostar), in which the water abundance of the hot component is about two orders of magnitude higher than that of the nearby colder component (Busquet et al. 2014). In the areas we estimated ortho-water abundance, the maximum CS excitation temperatures of G267.9–1.1, G268.4–0.9 and G336.5–1.5 are 165.2 K (and the second largest value is 86.6 K), 15.8 K and 42.3 K, respectively (and for G333.1–0.4, the average kinetic temperature is 31.9 K, according to Lowe et al. (2014)). For G267.9–1.1, there is a possibility that the warm component makes a big contribution to the origination of gaseous water. However, we cannot infer more information on structures smaller than the SWAS beam size which can further reveal the origination of gaseous water.
If the ortho-H2O 110 – 101 line originates from the same gas as CS lines, as we assumed when we estimated the ortho-water abundance, then the CS lines may help to find traces of outflows. The CS spectra of G267.9–1.1 have broad wings. We found that 267.9–1.1 as well as G268.4–0.9 does show velocity variation over the clump on its channel map, but the spatial resolution of CS data is not high enough to identify the outflows. Lapinov et al. (1998) have mapped G268.4–0.9 (G268.42–0.85) in CS (SEST, sampling spacing) and (the CSO telescope, sampling spacing) lines. They used the Maximum Entropy Method (MEM) deconvolution technique to achieve higher angular resolution (Lapinov et al. 1998). In their study, the CS (5–4) map shows two peaks with an LSR velocity difference of about 0.7 Km s*-1* and on the CS (7–6) map, a bipolar structure was identified but no further temperature information was offered for this bipolar structure (Lapinov et al. 1998).
To be honest and objective, it is kind of arbitrary to assume such a high density over the whole area in which we estimated the ortho-H2O abundance in each clump. There are very likely to be H2 density gradients in these areas. If we adopt 104 cm*-3* rather than 106 cm*-3* as the H2 density in the ortho-H2O abundance estimation, then the typical ortho-H2O abundances will be at the magnitude of 10*-8*, the same as those of most of the GMC cores in Snell et al. (2000b).
4.2 N2H+ Abundances
The N2H+ abundances of these four clumps are in the range of - for G267.9–1.1, - for G268.4–0.9, - for G333.1–0.4 and - for G336.5–1.5. The distribution of N2H+ abundance in each clump has a common decreasing trend toward the center. Although the abundance distributions we derived are only projected results in a plane perpendicular to the line of sight, we noticed that Melnick et al. (2011) suggested that N2H+ is likely to be distributed primarily in the clump rather than in the surface layers. When it comes to the depletion of N2H+, CO and electrons are the major destroyers of N2H+ in the gas phase and their reaction with N2H+ generates N2 (Aikawa et al. 2001, Aikawa et al. 2005). According to Bergin & Tafalla (2007), in the dense cores the neutrals (including CO) will rapidly freeze onto the grains. Consequently, the abundance of N2H+ will increase as a result of the disappearance of CO (Bergin & Tafalla 2007). However, when we focus on temperature, we notice that when the dust temperature rises from 10 K to about 30 K, CO begins to sublimate (van Dishoeck et al. 2013). Thus, based on the gas temperatures we estimated (the dust temperatures are approximately equal to local gas temperatures at such a high density as we had assumed), we can infer that in the high density center of the clump, the gas and dust are warm enough and the gaseous CO is abundant. N2H+ is therefore depleted by CO and that leads to a drop in N2H+ abundance toward the center.
5 conclusions
We studied G267.9–1.1, G268.4–0.9, G333.1–0.4 and G336.5–1.5, four of the brightest ortho-H2O sources in the southern sky observed by SWAS. We estimated their CS excitation temperatures in the CS (5–4)-traced areas and estimated their masses. Based on the temperatures and the masses, we then derived their average H2 column densities and estimated the ortho-H2O and N2H+ abundances.
The typical molecular clumps in our study have H2 column densities of to cm*-2* and ortho-H2O abundances of 10*-10*. The low ortho-H2O abundances can be caused by the freeze-out of H2O in the interior of the clumps due to the low temperatures if the ortho-H2O originates from the interior of the clumps.
The typical N2H+ abundances of these four clumps in this paper range from 10*-11* to 10*-9*. Since in the center areas of the clumps, dust at such a high density is at temperatures such that CO can be released into the gas phase, the common trend of abundance decreasing toward the center of the clump can be a result of the depletion of N2H+ caused by CO.
Acknowledgements.
We sincerely thank the anonymous referee and the scientific editor for their wholehearted and patient help and the valuable advice they provided to help us improve this paper. This research is supported by the National Basic Research Program of China (973 program, Nos. 2012CB821800 and 2015CB857100), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 11373038) and the Strategic Priority Research Program “The Emergence of Cosmological Structures” of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (Grant No. XDB09000000).
Appendix A Supplementary Material
In the temperature range (20 K to 80 K), para- and ortho-H2 are barely populated at energy levels other than = 0 and = 1 ( is the rotational level of H2), respectively. We adopted the effective rate coefficients at = 0 and = 1 from Dubernet et al. (2009) and Daniel et al. (2011).
For G267.9–1.1 and G336.5–1.5, we estimated the ortho-H2O abundance at the ortho-H2O integrated intensity maximum pixel in FITS format data. Although there is more than one sampling cell having emission in the CLASS format data, when written in FITS format, only the pixel with maximum integrated intensity (190190 arcsec2, the boxes with white dashed lines in Fig. 6) are located within the areas with calculated H2 column densities. However, the estimated ortho-H2O abundance of the pixels with maximum integrated intensity still characterize the ortho-H2O abundance of these clump in a sense. For G268.4–0.9 and G333.1–0.4, the CLASS format ortho-H2O data only have one sampling cell and the center of the cell is the same as the corresponding coordinates in Table 3 (with a deviation of 0.01 s on RA). So we just estimated the ortho-H2O abundance in the only sampling cell (the box with white dashed lines in Fig. 6, 190190 arcsec2, the same as the pixel size of the FITS format data).
We calculate the ortho-H2O abundance of G336.5–1.5 in the overlapping area of the white box (dashed lines) and the white box (solid lines) with corresponding average , average H2 column density and proportionally corrected ortho-H2O integrated intensity.
When calculating the partition functions of CS and N2H+, we summed the polynomial term by term from the level, following the incremental rotational quantum number. When the value of a term is less than 0.1% of the sum of all the terms of the lower levels, then this term will be the last term added in the summation.
The reference list from the paper itself. Each links out to its DOI / PubMed record.
- 1Aikawa et al. (2001) Aikawa, Y., Ohashi, N., Inutsuka, S.-i., Herbst, E., & Takakuwa, S. 2001, Ap J, 552, 639
- 2Aikawa et al. (2005) Aikawa, Y., Herbst, E., Roberts, H., & Caselli, P. 2005, Ap J, 620, 330
- 3Ashby et al. (2000) Ashby, M. L. N., Bergin, E. A., Plume, R., et al. 2000, Ap J, 539, L 115
- 4Balser (2006) Balser, D. S. 2006, AJ, 132, 2326
- 5Beard (1966) Beard, M. 1966, Australian Journal of Physics, 19, 141
- 6Bergin & Tafalla (2007) Bergin, E. A., & Tafalla, M. 2007, ARA&A, 45, 339
- 7Bergin & van Dishoeck (2012) Bergin, E. A., & van Dishoeck, E. F. 2012, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series A, 370, 2778
- 8Braz et al. (1989) Braz, M. A., Gregorio Hetem, J. C., Scalise, Jr., E., Monteiro Do Vale, J. L., & Gaylard, M. 1989, A&AS, 77, 465
