# Comment on "Spreading widths of giant resonances in spherical nuclei: damped transient response" by Severyukhin et al. [arXiv:1703.05710]

## TL;DR

This paper critically examines the universal approach proposed by Severyukhin et al. for describing spreading widths of giant resonances in spherical nuclei, questioning its validity and applicability.

## Contribution

It provides a critical analysis of the universality claim and assesses the approach's effectiveness in nuclear resonance modeling.

## Key findings

- Questions the validity of the universal approach
- Highlights limitations in the applicability of the method
- Suggests need for further validation and refinement

## Abstract

We argue whether physics of universal approach of Severyukhin et al. [arXiv:1703.05710] is approved.